Botchan 1732 Studios

Japanese · Botchan

五

Chapter 5

213 sentences · 19 notes

Tap a sentence to open its words. The mark beside it plays it.

  1. 1

    "Won't you come fishing?" Red Shirt asked me.

    君you君 · pronounsubject of 行き
    釣りfishing釣り · nounoblique complement of 行き
    にtoに · particleparticle marking 釣り
    行きgo行く · verbadverbial clause on 聞い
    ませ(polite)ます · auxiliary verbauxiliary of 行き
    んnotぬ · auxiliary verbauxiliary of 行き
    かquestionか · particleintroduces the clause of 行き
    とthatと · particleparticle marking 行き
    赤Red赤 · nouncompound with シャツ
    シャツShirtシャツ · nounsubject of 聞い
    がsubjectが · particleparticle marking シャツ
    おれmeおれ · pronounoblique complement of 聞い
    にtoに · particleparticle marking おれ
    聞いasked聞く · verbmain verb of the sentence
    た(past)た · auxiliary verbauxiliary of 聞い
  2. Red Shirt is the sort of man who puts on a voice so soft it's downright creepy.

  3. You genuinely can't tell whether it's a man or a woman talking.

  4. A man ought to make a man's voice.

  5. Especially since he's a university graduate.

  6. Even a fellow from physics school, like me, can manage a better voice than that — it's shameful for a bachelor of literature to sound like this.

  7. 2

    I gave the unenthusiastic answer of "I suppose so," and he asked the rude question of whether I'd ever been fishing.

  8. Not much, though as a child I once caught three crucian carp at the fishing pond in Koume.

  9. Then, at the Bishamon festival in Kagurazaka, I hooked a carp about nine and a half inches long, and just as I thought "got it," it plopped back into the water — I said even now I regret that — and Red Shirt stuck his chin out and laughed, "Ho ho ho ho."

  10. There was no need to laugh so affectedly about it — he could have just let it be.

  11. "Well then, you don't yet know the pleasure of fishing. If you like, I'll teach you a little," he said, looking terribly pleased with himself.

  12. As if I'd ever accept lessons from him.

  13. Generally speaking, everyone who fishes or hunts is a heartless sort of person.

  14. If they weren't heartless, they couldn't take pleasure in killing living things.

  15. Fish and birds alike would obviously rather be alive than be killed.

  16. If a man couldn't make a living without fishing or hunting, that would be one thing, but to be unable to sleep unless he has killed something living when he already wants for nothing is simply extravagant.

  17. I thought all this, but since the other man was a bachelor of literature and glib with words, I judged I couldn't win an argument, and kept quiet.

  18. Then, mistaking this for my surrender, the fellow said he'd teach me on the spot.

  19. If I was free, why not come along today?

  20. With just himself and Yoshikawa it would be lonely, he said, and kept pressing me to come.

  21. This Yoshikawa is the art teacher — the very Toady I mentioned before.

  22. For whatever reason, this Toady comes and goes at Red Shirt's house morning and night, and tags along wherever he goes.

  23. They're nothing like equals.

  24. It's more master and servant.

  25. Since Toady is bound to go wherever Red Shirt goes, none of that surprised me — but two of them alone would have done fine, so why bother inviting me, of all the unsociable people?

  26. No doubt it was some conceited fishing hobby of his, and he'd invited me only to show off his fishing to me.

  27. I'm not the sort to be impressed by that kind of showing off.

  28. Even if he hauled in two or three tuna, it wouldn't rattle me one bit.

  29. I'm human too — however poor a hand I am, if I just drop a line something is bound to bite; and if I refused to go, Red Shirt being the kind of man he is, would be sure to twist it into "he didn't come because he's bad at it," not "he didn't come because he doesn't care for it."

  30. Thinking all this over, I answered that I would go.

  31. After that I finished at school, went home once to get ready, and met Red Shirt and Toady at the station to go down to the beach.

  32. There was one boatman, and the boat had a long, slender shape I'd never seen anywhere around Tokyo.

  33. Looking around the boat, I hadn't spotted a single fishing rod.

  34. I asked Toady how one could possibly fish without a rod, and what he had in mind, and he stroked his chin and said, in that show-off way of his, that out at sea you don't use rods, just line.

  35. Better to have kept my mouth shut than get put in my place like that.

  36. 3

    The boatman rowed on slow and steady, but his skill was frightening — looking back, the shore already looked small, we were that far out.

  37. The five-storied pagoda of Kōhaku-ji poked up above the trees, sharp as a needle.

  38. Looking the other way, Blue Island floated on the water.

  39. They say nobody lives on it.

  40. Looking closely, it's nothing but rock and pine.

  41. No wonder — with nothing but rocks and pines, of course nobody could live there.

  42. Red Shirt kept gazing at it, saying what a fine view it was.

  43. Toady said it was a superb view.

  44. Superb or not, I couldn't say, but it certainly felt good.

  45. Out on that wide open sea, being blown by the salt wind — I thought it was as good as medicine.

  46. I was awfully hungry.

  47. "Look at that pine — the trunk dead straight, the top spread out like an umbrella, it looks like something out of a Turner," Red Shirt said to Toady, and Toady said, "Just like a Turner. That bend in it, really, nothing like it — it's the very image of a Turner," with a knowing look on his face.

  48. I had no idea what a Turner was, but since not knowing wouldn't trouble me any, I kept quiet.

  49. The boat circled round with the island on our right.

  50. There wasn't a wave anywhere.

  51. It was so flat it hardly seemed like the sea at all.

  52. Thanks to Red Shirt, it was turning into quite a pleasant outing.

  53. If it were possible I'd have liked to climb up onto that island, so I asked whether the boat could be brought in to that rocky spot.

  54. Red Shirt objected, saying it could be done, but you shouldn't fish too close to shore.

  55. I said nothing.

  56. Then Toady put in his unnecessary suggestion: "What do you say, Vice-Principal, shall we call that island Turner Island from now on?"

  57. Red Shirt agreed, saying that was a fine idea, that from now on they'd call it that.

  58. If I was included in that “we,” I wanted no part of it.

  59. Blue Island is plenty good enough a name for me.

  60. "What do you say we put a Raphael Madonna up on that rock?"

  61. Toady said what a fine picture that would make, and Red Shirt said, "Let's leave the Madonna out of it," laughing that creepy laugh of his — ho ho ho ho.

  62. "No one's around, so it's quite all right," he said, glancing at me for a moment, then deliberately turning his face away and smirking.

  63. Something about it left me with a bad feeling.

  64. Whether it's the Madonna or the young master or whoever, it's no business of mine, so they could go on setting her up wherever they liked — but he said things nobody could understand, then acted as if it did not matter if I heard because I would not understand.

  65. It was a low, vulgar way to carry on.

  66. And here the man goes around calling himself an Edo boy, of all things.

  67. I figured "Madonna" must be the nickname of some geisha Red Shirt is friendly with, or something of the sort.

  68. To have his favorite geisha stand under a pine tree on a deserted island and gaze at her — what an easy life.

  69. And then Toady would paint it in oils and put it up at an exhibition, no doubt.

  70. 4

    "This spot looks about right," said the boatman, stopping the boat and dropping anchor.

  71. "How many fathoms here?" asked Red Shirt, and the boatman said about six fathoms.

  72. "Six fathoms will make sea bream tricky," Red Shirt said, and cast his line into the water.

  73. The fellow seemed bent on catching sea bream — quite the bold ambition.

  74. Toady said, "No, with your skill, Vice-Principal, you'll get one."

  75. "And besides, the sea's dead calm," he flattered, and let out his own line and cast it in.

  76. All I could see was something like a lead sinker dangling at the end.

  77. There was no float.

  78. Fishing without a float is like taking a temperature without a thermometer.

  79. I couldn't imagine how it was done, and while I was watching, Red Shirt said, "Come now, you try it too — do you have line?"

  80. I said I had line to spare but no float, and he said anyone who can't fish without a float is an amateur.

  81. "Do it like this — when the line reaches the bottom, you gauge the vibrations with your forefinger at the gunwale; the moment it bites, it answers straight to your hand."

  82. "There — got one," he said, and suddenly began reeling in fast, and I thought something had caught, but nothing had — the bait was simply gone.

  83. Served him right.

  84. "Vice-Principal, what a shame — that was surely a big one just now, but if even your skill lets one get away, there's no being careless today."

  85. "Still, even getting away is something."

  86. "Better than the ones who just stare down a float."

  87. "It is just like being unable to ride a bicycle unless it has a brake.," Toady rattled on with all this nonsense.

  88. I very nearly wanted to belt him one.

  89. I'm human too — the vice-principal hasn't rented out the whole sea for himself.

  90. It's a wide place.

  91. Even a single bonito ought to bite out of decency at least, I thought, and I flung my sinker and line in with a plop and worked it idly with my fingertips.

  92. 5

    After a while something began tugging faintly at my line, twitch, twitch.

  93. I thought to myself.

  94. This has to be a fish.

  95. Nothing but a living thing would twitch like that.

  96. Got it — a bite! — and I hauled it in hand over hand.

  97. "Oh, did you catch one? The younger generation is a force to reckon with.," Toady jeered while the line, already mostly hauled in, had only some five feet or so still in the water.

  98. Peering over the gunwale, I saw a striped fish, something like a goldfish, stuck on the line, swaying side to side and rising up as I pulled.

  99. How interesting.

  100. As I brought it up out of the water it flopped, splashing salt water all over my face.

  101. I finally got hold of it and tried to take out the hook, but it wouldn't come loose easily.

  102. My hand, once I'd caught it, went all slimy.

  103. It was thoroughly unpleasant.

  104. Fed up with it, I shook the line and flung the thing down onto the floorboards, and it died at once.

  105. Red Shirt and Toady watched, looking startled.

  106. I washed my hands vigorously in the sea and held them up to my nose.

  107. They still smelled fishy.

  108. I'd had quite enough.

  109. I never wanted to hold another fish, whatever I caught.

  110. No doubt the fish didn't want to be held either.

  111. I wound up my line right then and there.

  112. 6

    "First catch, well done — but it's just a Gorki," Toady said with his usual cheek, and Red Shirt joked, "Gorki — sounds like the name of some Russian man of letters."

  113. "Just so, it really does sound like a Russian man of letters," Toady agreed at once.

  114. Gorki is a Russian man of letters, Maruki is a photographer in Shiba, and the rice-bearing tree is the source of life.

  115. This Red Shirt has a bad habit, really.

  116. Whoever he's talking to, he loves lining up katakana names for foreigners.

  117. Every man has his own field of expertise.

  118. A math teacher like me can hardly be expected to know Gorki from a cart-puller — he ought to hold back a little.

  119. If he wants to name-drop, he should use names even I know, like Franklin's autobiography, or Pushing to the Front.

  120. Red Shirt sometimes brings a bright red magazine called something like Imperial Literature to school and reads it as if it were a great treasure.

  121. I asked Porcupine about it, and apparently every one of Red Shirt's katakana names comes straight out of that magazine.

  122. Imperial Literature is a sinful sort of magazine.

  123. 7

    After that Red Shirt and Toady kept fishing with all their might, and in about an hour the two of them had pulled up fifteen or sixteen.

  124. Funnily enough, everything they caught, one after another, was nothing but Gorki.

  125. There wasn't a single sea bream to be had for love or money.

  126. "Today's a real windfall for Russian literature," Red Shirt said to Toady.

  127. "If even a man of your skill catches nothing but Gorki, there is no helping it if that is all a fellow like me can catch."

  128. "Naturally," Toady answered.

  129. I asked the boatman, and apparently this little fish has too many bones, tastes bad, and is quite inedible.

  130. It's only good for fertilizer, apparently.

  131. So Red Shirt and Toady were fishing fertilizer for all they were worth.

  132. What a pitiful thing.

  133. One fish had been quite enough for me, so I lay on my back on the floorboards and had been gazing up at the wide sky for some time.

  134. This was a great deal more elegant than fishing.

  135. 8

    Then the two of them began talking together in low voices.

  136. I couldn't make it out well, and anyway I had no wish to listen.

  137. I lay looking up at the sky, thinking about Kiyo.

  138. If I had money and could bring Kiyo to a lovely place like this, how pleasant it would be.

  139. However fine the scenery, it's no fun at all with the likes of Toady along.

  140. Kiyo is a wrinkled old woman, but I've never once felt embarrassed to take her anywhere.

  141. A man like Toady just wouldn't do — whether riding in a carriage, a boat, or up the Ryōunkaku tower, I could never keep company with a man like him..

  142. If I were vice-principal and Red Shirt were me, no doubt he'd come flattering up to me too, just to mock Red Shirt behind his back.

  143. People say Edo folk are shallow, and sure enough, when a man like this goes touring the provinces repeating "I'm an Edo boy" over and over, the country folk are bound to conclude that shallowness is the Edo way, and being an Edo boy means being shallow.

  144. While I was thinking all this, the two of them suddenly burst into snickering.

  145. Something was said between the bursts of laughter, but it came in fits and starts and I couldn't make head or tail of it.

  146. 9

    "Eh? I wonder..." "...quite so... since he doesn't know... it's a shame" "Surely not..." "The grasshoppers... it's true."

  147. 10

    I paid no attention to the rest of what was said, but the moment I heard Toady's word "grasshoppers" I couldn't help but stiffen.

  148. For some reason Toady put special weight on just that one word, "grasshoppers," making sure it reached my ears clearly, and then deliberately let the rest trail off into a mumble.

  149. I stayed still and went on listening all the same.

  150. 11

    "That Hotta fellow again..." "Could well be..." "Tempura... ha ha ha ha ha" "...stirred them up..." "The dumplings too?"

  151. 12

    The words came in such scattered fragments, but going by "grasshoppers," "tempura," and "dumplings," there was no doubt they were whispering about me behind my back.

  152. If they were going to talk, they might as well speak up; and if they were only going to whisper, they shouldn't have invited me along in the first place.

  153. What a disagreeable pair.

  154. Grasshoppers or straw sandals, whichever it was, the fault isn't mine.

  155. The principal told me to leave it in his hands for now, and out of deference to the Badger's face I've simply been holding back.

  156. And here's Toady, of all people, tossing out uncalled-for criticism.

  157. He'd do better to chew on his writing brush and keep quiet.

  158. Sooner or later I'll settle the whole business myself, so there's no real trouble there, but that phrase about "that Hotta fellow again" and "stirred them up" nags at me.

  159. I couldn't tell whether it meant Hotta had stirred me up to make the trouble bigger, or that Hotta had stirred up the students to bully me.

  160. As I looked up at the blue sky, the sunlight gradually weakened and a slightly chilly wind began to blow.

  161. Clouds like incense smoke drifted quietly along above the clear depths, and before I knew it they had flowed down into those depths and settled into a thin haze.

  162. 13

    "Shall we head back?" Red Shirt said, as if just remembering, and Toady said, "Yes, just about time."

  163. "Will you be seeing your Madonna tonight?" Toady said.

  164. Red Shirt said, "Don't talk nonsense, people will get the wrong idea," and straightened up a little from where he'd been leaning against the gunwale.

  165. "Eh heh heh heh, it's quite all right."

  166. As Toady turned back saying, "Even if he hears..." I fixed him with a stare like a pair of saucers, straight at the top of his head.

  167. Toady flinched as though dazzled, tumbling back, saying, "Ah, I surrender," and shrank his neck down, scratching his head.

  168. What an impudent little man.

  169. 14

    The boat rowed quietly back to shore over the calm sea.

  170. Red Shirt asked whether I didn't much care for fishing, and I answered that I'd rather lie back and look at the sky, and I flicked the half-smoked cigarette I'd lit into the sea, where it hissed and floated along, bobbing on the waves the oar's blade stirred up.

  171. "The students are all very pleased that you've come, so do give it your best," he said, bringing up something that had nothing at all to do with fishing.

  172. "I doubt they're all that pleased." "No, it's not flattery. They're genuinely pleased, aren't they, Yoshikawa?" "Pleased is putting it mildly. There's quite a stir," Toady said, grinning.

  173. It was strange how every single thing this fellow said got on my nerves.

  174. "Still, you'll want to be careful, it could get dangerous," Red Shirt said, and I answered, "Dangerous either way — if it comes to that, I'm prepared for danger."

  175. In truth I had it in mind to either get myself dismissed or make every last boarding student apologize, one or the other.

  176. "Put that way, there's no taking hold of it anywhere — but really, as vice-principal, I say this for your own good, don't take it the wrong way." "The headmaster genuinely has your interests at heart. For my part too, though I can't do much, being a fellow Edo man myself, I hope you'll stay on as long as possible, and we can help each other along — I've even been quietly doing what I can behind the scenes," Toady said, putting on his best show of humanity.

  177. I'd rather hang myself than be beholden to the likes of Toady.

  178. 15

    "So you see, the students are quite delighted you've come, but there are various circumstances involved. You may well have cause to be angry, but bear with it here, be patient, won't you. I'll never do anything against your interests."

  179. 16

    "What sort of various circumstances, exactly?"

  180. 17

    "That's rather complicated, but it'll gradually become clear. It'll come to you naturally, even without my telling you, won't it, Yoshikawa?"

  181. 18

    "Yes, it really is quite complicated. It can't be understood overnight, but it will gradually become clear — you'll come to understand it naturally, even without being told," Toady said, echoing Red Shirt's very words.

  182. 19

    "If it's such a troublesome business I needn't hear it, but since you brought it up yourself, I'm asking."

  183. 20

    "Quite right, of course. It would be irresponsible of me to open the subject and not follow through. Very well, let me just say this much. You, if I may say so, have only just graduated and this is your very first experience as a teacher. But a school is a place full of complicated personal interests, and things don't run along as simply as a student's plain thinking."

  184. 21

    "If it doesn't run along simply, how does it run, then?"

  185. 22

    "Well, you're so forthright that — that's just what I mean, you're still short on experience..."

  186. 23

    "Of course I'm short on experience. I even wrote it in my résumé — twenty-three years and four months."

  187. 24

    "There, that's exactly where you get taken advantage of from an unexpected quarter."

  188. 25

    "If a man behaves honestly, he needn't fear anyone taking advantage of him."

  189. 26

    "Of course you needn't fear it — you needn't, but it happens all the same. In fact your predecessor was caught out that way, so I say you should be careful."

  190. 27

    Noticing that Toady had gone quiet, I turned to look and found him already back at the stern, talking fishing with the boatman.

  191. With Toady out of earshot it was a good deal easier to talk.

  192. 28

    "What happened to my predecessor — who took advantage of him?"

  193. 29

    "Naming who would compromise that person's reputation, so I can't say. And besides, without clear proof, to say so would put the blame on me. In any case, now that you've gone to the trouble of coming here, it would be a shame for us if you failed after we called you all this way. Please do be careful."

  194. 30

    "However much you tell me to be careful, there's no more careful I can be than this. All I need to do is not do anything wrong, isn't that so?"

  195. 31

    Red Shirt laughed his "ho ho ho ho."

  196. I couldn't recall having said anything that deserved being laughed at.

  197. To this very day I still firmly believe I was right.

  198. Thinking it over, it seems most people in the world encourage each other to turn crooked.

  199. They seem to believe no one succeeds in society without becoming a little corrupt.

  200. Whenever they come across an honest, pure-hearted person, they find fault with him, calling him a "young master" or a “brat,” and look down on him.

  201. If that's so, ethics teachers in primary and middle schools would do better not to teach children not to lie and to be honest.

  202. They might as well go the whole way and teach, for everyone's good, methods for lying at school, techniques for distrusting others, and strategies for taking people in.

  203. When Red Shirt laughed his "ho ho ho ho," he was laughing at how simple I am.

  204. If a world laughs at simplicity and sincerity, there's nothing to be done about it.

  205. Kiyo never once laughed at me at a time like this.

  206. She always listened with great admiration.

  207. Kiyo is a far finer person than Red Shirt.

  208. 32

    "Of course it's fine so long as you don't do anything wrong yourself, but even if you personally do nothing wrong, if you can't tell when others are up to no good, you'll surely come to grief all the same. In this world there are people who, however open-hearted or easygoing they look, however kindly they see to your lodgings, are the very ones you can least afford to let your guard down with... It's turned quite cold. Autumn's really here now — look, the shore's gone sepia with the mist. What a fine sight. Hey, Yoshikawa, what do you say, that view of the shore..." he called out loudly to Toady.

  209. "Well now, that really is a marvel."

  210. "If I had the time I'd sketch it — a shame to leave it just as it is," Toady said, laying it on thick.

  211. 33

    A single light came on in the second floor of the Minatoya, and just as a train whistle let out a hoot, the boat I was riding in ran its prow grating up into the sandy beach and came to a stop.

  212. "Back early, aren’t you?," the innkeeper's wife said, standing on the shore, greeting Red Shirt.

  213. I jumped down from the side of the boat onto the beach at last, with a heave-ho.

The particulars

The text
坊っちゃん, Natsume Sōseki. Botchan.
Translation
Public-domain Japanese (Natsume Sōseki, d. 1916; published 1906). English translation © 2026 1732 Studios, LLC.
Reading aloud
Digital narration, directed by 1732 Studios.
Words
Every word of the text, by letter.
Data
JSON · Markdown · A guide for agents
Two whoopie pies and a pine. An inside joke.