Max Havelaar 1732 Studios

Dutch · The Novel

Hoofdstuk 14

Chapter 14

317 sentences · 437 notes

Tap a sentence to open its words. The mark beside it plays it.

  1. 1

    CHAPTER FOURTEEN

    VEERTIENDEfourteenthveertiende · ordinal numeral, attributivemodifies HOOFDSTUK
    HOOFDSTUKchapterhoofdstuk · noun, neuter, singularhead of the title
  2. 2

    You know, Havelaar began, how the Dutch possessions on the west coast of Sumatra border on the independent realms in the northern corner, of which Atjeh is the most considerable.

  3. 3

    It is said that a secret article in the treaty of 1824 binds us, with respect to the English, not to cross the river of Singkel.

  4. 4

    General Vandamme, who with a faux-air of Napoleon was fond of extending his governorship as far as possible, thus ran up against an insurmountable obstacle in that direction.

  5. 5

    I am inclined to believe in the existence of that secret article, for otherwise it would surprise me that the Rajahs of Troeman and Analaboe, whose provinces are of no small weight on account of the pepper trade carried on there, had not long since been brought under Dutch sovereignty.

  6. 6

    You know how easily one finds a pretext for making war on such little lands and seizing them for oneself.

  7. 7

    Stealing a region will always remain easier than stealing a windmill.

  8. 8

    I believe of General Vandamme that he would have made off with a windmill itself had he taken a fancy to it, and so I cannot suppose that he would have spared those northern regions had there not been firmer grounds for it than justice and equity.

  9. 9

    However that may be, he turned his conqueror's gaze not northward but eastward.

  10. 10

    The territories of Mandhéling and Ankola — this was the name of the assistant-residency formed out of the newly pacified Battah lands — were indeed not yet cleansed of Atjinese influence, for wherever fanaticism once takes root it is hard to dig out, but the Atjinese themselves were no longer there. This, however, was not enough for the Governor.

  11. 11

    He extended his authority all the way to the east coast, and Dutch officials and Dutch garrisons were sent to Bila and Pertibie, posts which — as you know, Verbrugge — were later evacuated again. When a Government Commissioner arrived on Sumatra who found this expansion pointless and disapproved of it on that account, chiefly too because it conflicted with the desperate economy on which the motherland so strongly insisted, General Vandamme maintained that the expansion need have no burdensome effect on the budget, for the new garrisons had been formed out of troops for which funds had already in any case been granted, so that he had brought a very large region under Dutch administration without any monetary outlay flowing from it.

  12. 12

    And as for the partial stripping of other places, chiefly in the Mandhéling country, he thought he could rely sufficiently on the loyalty and devotion of Jang di Pertoean, the foremost chief in the Battah lands, to see no difficulty in it.

  13. 13

    With reluctance the Government Commissioner gave way, and only on the general's repeated assurances that he stood surety personally for Jang di Pertoean's loyalty.

  14. 14

    Now the controller who governed the Natal division before me was the son-in-law of the assistant-resident in the Battah lands, an official who was on bad terms with Jang di Pertoean.

  15. 15

    Later I heard much talk of complaints that had been brought against that assistant-resident, yet one had to be cautious in giving credence to these accusations, since they came largely from the mouth of Jang di Pertoean, and at a moment, moreover, when he himself stood accused of far graver offenses, which perhaps prompted him to seek his own defense in the faults of his accuser ... as happens often enough.

  16. 16

    However that may be, the chief officer of Natal embraced the cause of his father-in-law against Jang di Pertoean, and the more ardently perhaps because that controller was on very friendly terms with a certain Soetan Salim, a Natal chief who was likewise much incensed against the Battah chief.

  17. 17

    A feud had long reigned between the families of these two chiefs. Marriage proposals had been refused, there was jealousy over influence, pride on the part of Jang di Pertoean, who was of better birth, and still other causes ran together to keep Natal and Mandhéling set against each other.

  18. 18

    All at once the rumor spread that a plot had been uncovered in Mandhéling, in which Jang di Pertoean was supposedly implicated, and which aimed at raising the holy banner of revolt and murdering all the Europeans.

  19. 19

    The first discovery of this had taken place at Natal, which is natural, since in neighboring provinces one is always better informed of the state of affairs than on the spot itself, because many who at home are held back by fear of an implicated chief from disclosing some circumstance known to them, master that fear to some degree the moment they find themselves on a territory where that chief has no influence.

  20. 20

    This, then, is also the reason, Verbrugge, why I am no stranger to the affairs of Lebak, and why I knew a fair amount of what goes on here before I ever thought I would be posted here.

  21. 21

    In 1846 I was in the Krawang country, and I roamed widely through the Preanger, where as early as 1840 I had met émigrés from Lebak.

  22. 22

    I am also acquainted with some of the owners of private estates in the Buitenzorg country and in the lands around Batavia, and I know how those landlords have from of old rejoiced over the wretched condition of this division, because it peoples their estates.

  23. 23

    So too, then, the conspiracy was said to have been uncovered at Natal which — if it ever existed, which I do not know — exposed Jang di Pertoean as a traitor.

  24. 24

    According to depositions of witnesses taken down by the controller of Natal, he was said, together with his brother Soetan Adam, to have gathered the Battah chiefs in a sacred grove, where they were supposed to have sworn not to rest until the authority of the "Christian dogs" in Mandhéling was destroyed.

  25. 25

    It goes without saying that for this he had received an inspiration from heaven. You know that on such occasions this is never lacking.

  26. 26

    Whether this design ever in fact existed in Jang di Pertoean's mind, I cannot affirm. I have read the witnesses' depositions, but you will see at once why no unconditional credence may be placed in them.

  27. 27

    Certain it is that the man, so far as his Islamic fanaticism is concerned, may well have been capable of such a thing.

  28. 28

    He had, along with the whole Battah population, only shortly before been won over to the true faith by the Padris, and the newly converted are usually fanatical.

  29. 29

    The consequence of that true or supposed discovery was that Jang di Pertoean was taken prisoner by the assistant-resident of Mandhéling and sent to Natal. Here the controller shut him up provisionally in the fort, and had him conveyed in custody to Padang by the first suitable opportunity by sea.

  30. 30

    It goes without saying that all the documents in which the so incriminating testimonies were recorded, and which had to justify the severity of the measures taken, were laid before the Governor. Our Jang di Pertoean thus departed from Mandhéling as a prisoner.

  31. 31

    At Natal he was a prisoner. Aboard the man-of-war that carried him over, he was naturally a prisoner as well.

  32. 32

    He therefore expected — guilty or not, that has nothing to do with the matter, since he had in lawful form and by a competent authority been accused of high treason — to arrive at Padang as a prisoner too.

  33. 33

    He must indeed have stood greatly astonished, on disembarking, to learn not only that he was free, but that the general, whose carriage awaited him as he stepped ashore, would count it an honor to receive and lodge him in his own house. Surely no man accused of high treason was ever more agreeably surprised.

  34. 34

    Shortly after this the assistant-resident of Mandhéling was suspended from his post on account of all manner of offenses which I do not here judge. Jang di Pertoean, however, after lodging some time at Padang in the general's house, and after being treated by him with the utmost distinction, returned by way of Natal to Mandhéling, not with the self-assurance of a man declared innocent, but with the pride of one who stands so high that he needs no declaration of innocence.

  35. 35

    For, after all, the matter had not been investigated! Granting that the accusation brought against him was held to be false, then this very suspicion already called for an inquiry, in order to punish the false witnesses, and above all those who might appear to have procured such falsehood.

  36. 36

    It seems that the general had his reasons for not letting this inquiry take place. The charge brought against Jang di Pertoean was treated as null and void, and I hold it for certain that the documents bearing on it never came before the eyes of the Government at Batavia.

  37. 37

    Shortly after Jang di Pertoean's return I arrived at Natal to take over the administration of that division.

  38. 38

    My predecessor naturally recounted to me what had recently occurred in the Mandhéling country, and gave me the necessary information about the political relations between that region and my division.

  39. 39

    It was not to be held against him that he complained bitterly of the, in his view, unjust treatment that had befallen his father-in-law, and of the incomprehensible protection that Jang di Pertoean evidently enjoyed from the general.

  40. 40

    Neither he nor I knew at that moment that the sending of Jang di Pertoean to Batavia would have been a blow in the face for that general, and that he — having stood surety personally for that chief's loyalty — had well-founded reasons, whatever it might cost, to shield him from an accusation of high treason.

  41. 41

    This was all the more important for the general because in the meantime the very Government Commissioner just referred to had himself become Governor-General, and would therefore in all likelihood have recalled him from his governorship, out of vexation at the unfounded confidence placed in Jang di Pertoean, and at the obstinacy resting on it with which the general had resisted the evacuation of the east coast.

  42. 42

    "But," said my predecessor, "whatever may move the general to accept out of hand all the accusations against my father-in-law, and to deem the far graver charges against Jang di Pertoean not even worth an inquiry, the matter is not finished!

  43. 43

    And if at Padang, as I surmise, they have destroyed the depositions that were taken, here is something else that cannot be destroyed."

  44. 44

    And he showed me a sentence of the Rappat-council at Natal, of which he was president, containing: SENTENCE OF A CERTAIN Si Pamaga TO THE PENALTY OF FLOGGING AND BRANDING, AND — I believe — TWENTY YEARS' HARD LABOR, FOR ATTEMPTED MURDER OF THE TOEANKOE OF NATAL.

  45. 45

    "Just read the record of the trial," said my predecessor, "and then judge whether my father-in-law will not be believed at Batavia when he charges Jang di Pertoean there with high treason!

  46. 46

    I read the documents.

  47. 47

    According to the witnesses' depositions and "the confession of the accused," Si Pamaga had been bribed to murder the Toeankoe at Natal, together with his foster-father Soetan Salim and the controller in charge.

  48. 48

    To carry out this design he had gone to the dwelling of the Toeankoe, and there struck up a conversation about a Sewah with the servants sitting on the steps of the outer gallery, with the aim of prolonging his presence until he should catch sight of the Toeankoe, who indeed soon appeared, surrounded by some of his kinsmen and servants.

  49. 49

    Pamaga had rushed at the Toeankoe with his Sewah, but for reasons unknown had been unable to carry out his murderous design.

  50. 50

    The Toeankoe, terrified, had leapt out of the window, and Pamaga took to flight. He hid himself in the forest, and some days later was apprehended by the Natal police.

  51. 51

    "Asked of the accused: what had moved him to this assault and the intended murder of Soetan Salim and the controller of Natal?" he answers: "THAT HE HAD BEEN BRIBED TO IT BY SOETAN ADAM, IN THE NAME OF HIS BROTHER JANG DI PERTOEAN OF MANDHÉLING."

  52. 52

    "Is this clear or not?" asked my predecessor.

  53. 53

    The sentence has, after the resident's fiat of execution, been carried out as regards the flogging and the branding, and Si Pamaga is on his way to Padang, to be sent from there as a chain-gang convict to Java.

  54. 54

    Along with him the case papers reach Batavia, and then they can see there who the man is on whose accusation my father-in-law was suspended!

  55. 55

    That sentence the general cannot annul, even if he wished to."

  56. 56

    I took over the administration of the Natal division, and my predecessor departed.

  57. 57

    After some time I received notice that the general would come up north in a war steamer and would visit Natal as well.

  58. 58

    He alighted at my house with a large retinue, and at once demanded to see the original case papers of: "the poor man who had been so frightfully ill-treated."

  59. 59

    "They themselves had deserved a flogging and a branding!" he added.

  60. 60

    I could make nothing of it.

  61. 61

    For the causes of the quarrel over Jang di Pertoean were still unknown to me then, and so it could not enter my thoughts, any more than that my predecessor would willfully and knowingly have condemned an innocent man to so heavy a penalty, that the general would take a criminal under his protection against a just sentence.

  62. 62

    I received the order to have Soetan Salim and the Toeankoe taken prisoner.

  63. 63

    Since the young Toeankoe was much beloved among the people, and we had only a small garrison in the fort, I asked the general to be allowed to leave him at liberty, which was granted me. But for Soetan Salim, the particular enemy of Jang di Pertoean, there was no mercy.

  64. 64

    The population was in great suspense.

  65. 65

    The people of Natal suspected that the general was lowering himself to be an instrument of Mandhéling hatred, and it was in these circumstances that from time to time I could do something he found "resolute," especially since he would not turn over to me, as a guard when I rode out to the places where people were gathering, the little force that could be spared from the fort, nor the detachment of marines he had brought along from on board. I noticed on that occasion that General Vandamme took very good care of his own safety, and it is for that reason that I cannot endorse his reputation for bravery until I have seen more of it, or something else.

  66. 66

    In great haste he formed a council, which I might call an ad hoc one. Its members were: a couple of adjutants, other officers, the officer of Justice or fiscal, whom he had brought along from Padang, and myself.

  67. 67

    This council was to hold an inquiry into the manner in which, under my predecessor, the case against Si Pamaga had been conducted.

  68. 68

    I had to have summoned a number of witnesses whose depositions were needed for this.

  69. 69

    The general, who naturally presided, did the questioning, and the records were written down by the fiscal.

  70. 70

    Since, however, this official understood little Malay — and by no means the Malay spoken in the north of Sumatra — it was often necessary to interpret the witnesses' answers for him, which the general for the most part did himself.

  71. 71

    From the sittings of that council documents emerged which seem to prove most plainly: that Si Pamaga had never harbored the intention of murdering anyone whomsoever. That he had never seen or known either Soetan Adam or Jang di Pertoean.

  72. 72

    That he had not sprung upon the Toeankoe of Natal. That the latter had not fled out of the window ... and so forth!

  73. 73

    Further: that the sentence against the unfortunate Si Pamaga had been passed under pressure from the president — my predecessor — and from the councilman Soetan Salim, persons who had invented Si Pamaga's pretended crime in order to put into the hand of the suspended assistant-resident of Mandhéling a weapon for his own defense, and to give vent to their hatred of Jang di Pertoean.

  74. 74

    Now the manner in which the general questioned on that occasion called to mind the game of whist played by a certain emperor of Morocco who said to his partner: "play hearts, or I cut your throat." The translations too, as he dictated them to the fiscal, left much to be desired.

  75. 75

    Whether Soetan Salim and my predecessor brought pressure to bear on the Natal court of justice to declare Si Pamaga guilty, I do not know. But this I do know, that General Vandamme brought pressure to bear on the depositions that were to prove the man's innocence.

  76. 76

    Without yet grasping at that moment what it was leading to, I set myself against that ... inaccuracy, and this went so far that I had to refuse to co-sign certain records, and there you have the matter in which I had so "thwarted" the general.

  77. 77

    You now also understand what those words point to with which I closed my reply to the remarks that had been made on my financial management, the words in which I asked to be spared all benevolent consideration.

  78. 78

    — It was indeed very bold for a man of your years, said Duclari.

  79. 79

    — I thought it natural. Yet certain it is that General Vandamme was not used to such a thing.

  80. 80

    And I did indeed suffer much from the consequences of that affair.

  81. 81

    Oh no, Verbrugge, I see what you mean to say — I have never regretted it.

  82. 82

    Indeed, I must add here that I would not have confined myself to a simple protest against the way the general questioned the witnesses, nor to refusing my signature on a few records, had I been able to guess then what I only learned later, that the whole thing sprang from a design settled beforehand to incriminate my predecessor.

  83. 83

    I supposed that the general, convinced of Si Pamaga's innocence, was being carried away by the honorable desire to save an innocent victim from the consequences of a miscarriage of justice, in so far as that was still possible after the flogging and the branding.

  84. 84

    This supposition did indeed make me rise up against falsehood, but I was not so indignant over it as I would have been had I known that it was here by no means a matter of saving an innocent man, but that this falsehood had the purpose of destroying — at the cost of my predecessor's honor and well-being — the evidence that stood in the way of the general's policy.

  85. 85

    — And how did it go further with your predecessor? asked Verbrugge.

  86. 86

    — Luckily for him he had already left for Java before the general returned to Padang.

  87. 87

    He seems to have been able to justify himself before the Government at Batavia; at any rate he remained in service.

  88. 88

    The resident of Ayer Bangie who had granted the fiat of execution on the sentence, was ...

  89. 89

    — Suspended?

  90. 90

    — Naturally!

  91. 91

    You see that I was not so very wrong, in my epigram, to say that the Governor governed us by suspension.

  92. 92

    — And what became of all those suspended officials?

  93. 93

    — Oh, there were many more of them still!

  94. 94

    All of them, one before, another after, were restored to their posts.

  95. 95

    Some of them later held very considerable offices.

  96. 96

    — And Soetan Salim?

  97. 97

    — The general carried him off in custody to Padang, and from there he was sent into exile to Java.

  98. 98

    He is to this day still at Tjanjor in the Preanger regencies.

  99. 99

    When I was there in 1846, I paid him a visit.

  100. 100

    Do you still remember what I came to Tjanjor to do, Tine?

  101. 101

    — No, Max, that has slipped my mind entirely.

  102. 102

    — Who, after all, can remember everything?

  103. 103

    I was married there, gentlemen!

  104. 104

    — But, asked Duclari, since you are telling stories now anyway, may I ask whether it is true that you fought duels so often at Padang?

  105. 105

    — Yes, very often, and there was reason for it.

  106. 106

    I have already told you that on such an outpost the Governor's favor is the yardstick by which many measure their good will.

  107. 107

    Most, then, were very ill-disposed toward me, and often this passed over into rudeness.

  108. 108

    I, for my part, was irritable.

  109. 109

    An unreturned greeting, a sneer at the "folly of a man who wants to take on the general," an allusion to my poverty, to my going hungry, to the poor nourishment that seemed to lie in moral independence ... all this, you understand, made me bitter. Many, especially among the officers, knew that the general was not displeased to see duels fought, and above all with someone so out of favor as I was.

  110. 110

    So perhaps my sensitivity was roused on purpose. I also dueled now and then on behalf of another whom I held to have been wronged.

  111. 111

    However that may be, the duel was in those days the order of the day there, and more than once it happened that I had two meetings in one morning. Oh, there is something very attractive in the duel, especially with the saber, or "on" the saber, as they call it ... I do not know why.

  112. 112

    You understand, however, that I would no longer do such a thing now, even were there as much occasion for it as in those days ... come here, Max — no, do not catch that little creature — come here?

  113. 113

    Listen, you must never catch butterflies.

  114. 114

    That poor creature first crept about for a long while as a caterpillar on a tree — that was no merry life!

  115. 115

    Now it has only just gotten its little wings, and wants to fly about a bit in the air, and amuse itself, and it seeks food in the flowers, and harms no one ... look, is it not far prettier to see it flutter about there like that?

  116. 116

    So the conversation passed from the duels to the butterflies, to the mercy of the righteous man toward his beast, to the tormenting of animals, to the loi Grammont, to the National Assembly in which that law was passed, to the republic, and to what not! At last Havelaar rose.

  117. 117

    He excused himself to his guests, since he had business to attend to.

  118. 118

    When the controller called on him at his office the next morning, he did not know that the new assistant-resident, the previous day after the conversations in the front gallery, had ridden out to Parang-Koedjang — the district of the "far-reaching abuses" — and had returned from there only early that morning. * * * * *

  119. 119

    I beg the reader to believe that Havelaar was too well-bred to speak as much at his own table as I have set down in the last chapters, whereby I cast upon him the appearance of having monopolized the conversation, neglecting the duties of a host, which prescribe that one give or afford one's guests the opportunity "to show themselves to advantage." Out of the many materials lying before me, I have made a few selections, and could have continued the table talk for a long while yet, with less effort than breaking it off has cost me.

  120. 120

    I hope, however, that what has been related will suffice to justify in some measure the description I have given of Havelaar's character and qualities, and that the reader will not look on entirely without interest at the fortunes that awaited him and his family at Rangkas-Betoeng.

  121. 121

    The little family went on living quietly.

  122. 122

    Havelaar was often out during the day, and spent half his nights at his office.

  123. 123

    The relationship between him and the commander of the small garrison was of the most agreeable kind, and in his domestic dealings with the controller, too, there was no trace to be found of that difference in rank which otherwise so often makes social life in the Indies stiff and tedious; while moreover Havelaar's eagerness to lend a hand wherever he in any way could often came to the aid of the Regent, who for his part was very well disposed toward his "elder brother." And finally the graciousness of Mrs. Havelaar contributed much to the pleasant intercourse with the few Europeans present at the post and with the Native Chiefs.

  124. 124

    The official correspondence with the resident at Serang bore the marks of mutual goodwill, while the resident's orders, given courteously, were carried out to the letter.

  125. 125

    Tine's household was soon set in order.

  126. 126

    After long waiting the furniture had arrived from Batavia, and cucumbers had been laid down in salt, and when Max told some story at table it was henceforth no longer from a want of eggs for the omelette, though even so the way of life of the small family always bore clear signs that the intended thrift was being closely observed.

  127. 127

    Mrs. Slotering rarely left her house, and only a few times took tea with the Havelaar family in the front gallery.

  128. 128

    She spoke little, and kept a watchful eye at all times on everyone who approached her dwelling or Havelaar's. People had grown used, however, to what they had begun to call her monomania, and soon paid it no further heed.

  129. 129

    Everything seemed to breathe calm, for to Max and Tine it was comparatively a trifle to resign themselves to the privations that are unavoidable at an inland post which does not lie along the great highway.

  130. 130

    Since no bread was baked at the post, they ate no bread.

  131. 131

    It could have been brought in from Serang, but the cost of that transport was too high.

  132. 132

    Max knew as well as anyone else that there were plenty of means of having bread carried to Rangkas-Betoeng without payment, but unpaid labor, that Indian cancer, was an abomination to him.

  133. 133

    Thus there was much at Lebak that authority could indeed obtain for nothing but that was not to be bought at a fair price, and under such conditions Havelaar and his Tine gladly accommodated themselves to going without.

  134. 134

    They had known other privations indeed!

  135. 135

    Had that poor woman not spent months aboard an Arab vessel, with no other bed than the ship's deck, no other shelter against the heat of the sun and the squalls of the west monsoon than a little table between whose legs she had to cling fast?

  136. 136

    Had she not been obliged, on that ship, to content herself with a small ration of dry rice and foul water?

  137. 137

    And had she not, in those and many other circumstances, always been content, so long as she might only be together with her Max?

  138. 138

    There was, however, one circumstance at Lebak that caused her grief: little Max could not play in the garden, because there were so many snakes there.

  139. 139

    When she noticed this and complained of it to Havelaar, he offered the servants a reward for every snake they should catch; but already in the first days he paid out so much in bounties that he had to withdraw his promise for the future, for even under ordinary circumstances, and thus apart from the thrift so necessary for him, that payment would soon have exceeded his means.

  140. 140

    It was therefore settled that little Max should henceforth no longer leave the house, and that, to take the fresh air, he must content himself with playing in the front gallery.

  141. 141

    In spite of this precaution Tine was nevertheless always anxious, and above all in the evenings, since one knows how snakes often creep into the houses and, to seek warmth, hide themselves in the bedrooms.

  142. 142

    Snakes and such vermin are, it is true, to be found everywhere in the Indies, but in the larger principal towns, where the population lives more closely together, they naturally occur more seldom than in wilder regions, such as Rangkas-Betoeng.

  143. 143

    If, however, Havelaar had been able to bring himself to have his grounds cleared of weeds all the way to the edge of the ravine, the snakes would no doubt still have shown themselves in the garden from time to time, but not in such great numbers as was now the case.

  144. 144

    The nature of these creatures makes them prefer darkness and concealment to the light of open places, so that, had Havelaar's grounds been kept tidy, the snakes would have left the thicket in the ravine only, as it were, in spite of themselves and by going astray.

  145. 145

    But Havelaar's grounds were not tidy, and I wish to set out the reason for this, since it casts one more glance upon the abuses that prevail almost everywhere in the Dutch East Indian possessions.

  146. 146

    The dwellings of the administrators in the interior stand on lands that belong to the communities, in so far as one can speak of communal property in a country where the Government appropriates everything to itself.

  147. 147

    Enough to say that these grounds do not belong to the official occupant himself.

  148. 148

    For he, were this the case, would beware of buying or renting a ground whose upkeep lay beyond his means.

  149. 149

    Now when the grounds of the dwelling assigned to him are too large to be properly maintained, this would, given the rank tropical growth of plants, degenerate within a short time into a wilderness.

  150. 150

    And yet one seldom or never sees such grounds in poor condition. Indeed, often enough the traveler stands astonished at the handsome park that surrounds a resident's dwelling.

  151. 151

    No officer in the interior has income enough to have the labor needed for this performed against proper payment, and since after all a dignified appearance of the administrator's dwelling is a requirement, lest the population, which sets so much store by outward show, find in slovenliness a ground for contempt, the question arises: how, then, is this end attained?

  152. 152

    In most places the administrators have at their disposal a number of chain-gang men, that is to say: malefactors sentenced elsewhere — a sort of laborer, however, which in Bantam, for reasons of a political nature more or less valid, was not to be had.

  153. 153

    But even in places where such convicts are indeed to be found, their number, especially considering the need for other labor, is seldom in proportion to the work that would be required for the good upkeep of a large grounds.

  154. 154

    Other means must therefore be found, and the summoning of laborers to perform statute-labor lies ready to hand.

  155. 155

    The Regent or the Dhemang who receives such a summons hastens to comply with it, for he knows very well that the administrator who abuses that authority would later find it difficult to punish a native Chief for a like offence. And so the transgression of the one becomes a free pass for the other.

  156. 156

    It seems to me, however, that such a fault on an administrator's part ought in some cases not to be judged too severely, and above all not by European standards.

  157. 157

    For the population itself would — perhaps out of sheer unfamiliarity — find it very strange if he always and in every case held strictly to the regulations that prescribe the number of statute-laborers allotted for his grounds, since circumstances may arise that these regulations did not foresee.

  158. 158

    But once the boundary of the strictly lawful has been overstepped, it becomes difficult to fix a point at which such overstepping would pass into criminal arbitrariness, and above all great circumspection becomes necessary as soon as one knows that the Chiefs are merely waiting for a bad example, in order to follow it with far-reaching extension.

  159. 159

    The tale of a certain king who would not have the payment omitted of a single grain of salt that he had used at his simple meal, when at the head of his army he passed through the land — because, as he said, this was the beginning of an injustice that would in the end ruin his whole kingdom — whether he was called Tamerlane, Nureddin, or Genghis Khan, certain it is that either that fable, or, if it be no fable, the incident itself, is of Asiatic origin. And just as the sight of sea-dikes makes one believe in the possibility of high water, so one may assume that there exists an inclination toward such abuses in a land where such lessons are given.

  160. 160

    Now the small number of men over whom Havelaar could lawfully dispose were able to keep free of weeds and brushwood only a very small portion of his grounds, in the immediate vicinity of the dwelling.

  161. 161

    The rest was, within a few weeks, an utter wilderness.

  162. 162

    Havelaar wrote to the resident about the means of providing for this, whether by a money allowance, or by proposing to the Government that, as elsewhere, chain-gang men be set to labor in the residency of Bantam.

  163. 163

    He received to this a refusing answer, with the remark that he surely had the right to set to work on his grounds the persons whom he had sentenced by police verdict to "labor on the public road." This Havelaar well knew, or at any rate it was more than sufficiently known to him that such disposal over the condemned was everywhere the most ordinary thing in the world; but never had he wished, neither at Rangkas-Betoeng nor at Amboina, nor at Menado, nor at Natal, to make use of that supposed right.

  164. 164

    It went against him to have his garden maintained as a penalty for petty offences, and more than once he had asked himself how the Government could let stand regulations that may tempt the official to punish small, excusable faults, not in proportion to the offence, but according to the condition or the extent of his grounds.

  165. 165

    The mere thought that the man punished — even he who had been justly punished — would suppose that self-interest lay hidden beneath the sentence handed down, made him, where he had to punish, always prefer the otherwise highly objectionable confinement.

  166. 166

    And from this it came that little Max was not allowed to play in the garden, and that Tine, too, took not so much pleasure in the flowers as she had imagined to herself on the day of her arrival at Rangkas-Betoeng.

  167. 167

    It goes without saying that these and similar small vexations had no influence on the mood of a family that possessed so much material for procuring itself a happy domestic life, and it was therefore not to be ascribed to such trifles when Havelaar sometimes entered with a clouded brow, on returning from an excursion, or after hearing out this person and that who had asked to speak with him.

  168. 168

    We have heard from his address to the Chiefs that he meant to do his duty, that he meant to oppose injustice, and at the same time I hope that the reader has, from the conversations I reported, come to know him as someone well able to find a thing out and bring it to light that for some others lay hidden or in the dark.

  169. 169

    It was therefore to be supposed that not much of what went on in Lebak would escape his notice.

  170. 170

    We also saw that he had, many years before, given his attention to that district, so that already on the first day, when Verbrugge met him in the pendopo where my story begins, he showed himself to be no stranger to his new sphere of work.

  171. 171

    Through inquiry on the spot itself he had found much of what he formerly suspected confirmed, and above all it had become clear to him from the archive that the region whose administration was entrusted to his care was really in a most lamentable condition.

  172. 172

    From letters and notes of his predecessor he perceived that the latter had made the same observations.

  173. 173

    The correspondence with the Chiefs contained reproach upon reproach, threat upon threat, and made it very plainly understood how that official would at last have said that he would apply directly to the Government if an end were not put to that state of affairs.

  174. 174

    When Verbrugge reported this to Havelaar, the latter had answered that his predecessor would have done wrong in that, since the assistant resident of Lebak might in no case pass over the resident of Bantam; and he had added that this would also be justified by absolutely nothing, since it was, after all, not to be thought that such a high officer would take the part of extortion and oppression.

  175. 175

    Such taking of a part was indeed truly not to be supposed in the sense that Havelaar meant it, namely not as though some advantage or gain would fall to the resident's share from those offences. But there did exist a cause that moved him to do justice to the complaints of Havelaar's predecessor only most reluctantly.

  176. 176

    We have seen how that predecessor had spoken with the resident more than once about the prevailing abuses — had a heart-to-heart, Verbrugge said — and how little this had availed him.

  177. 177

    It is therefore not without importance to examine why an officer so highly placed, who as head of the whole residency was just as bound as the assistant resident — indeed, more so than he — to see that justice was done, almost always believed he had reason to arrest the course of that justice.

  178. 178

    Already at Serang, when Havelaar was staying there at the resident's house, he had spoken to him about the abuses of Lebak, and had received in answer: "that all this was, in greater or lesser measure, the case everywhere." Now this Havelaar could not deny.

  179. 179

    For who would claim to have seen a country where nothing wrong is done?

  180. 180

    But he held that this was no reason to let abuses, where one found them, continue to exist, above all not when one had been expressly called to counter them; and at the same time that, after all he knew of Lebak, there was here no question of greater or lesser, but of very great measure — to which the resident answered him, among other things: "that in the district of Tjiringien — likewise belonging to Bantam — things were in a still worse state."

  181. 181

    When one now assumes, as one may assume, that a resident has no direct advantage from extortion and from arbitrary disposal over the population, the question arises: what then moves so many, in contradiction with oath and duty, to let such abuses continue to exist, without giving knowledge of them to the Government?

  182. 182

    And whoever reflects on this must find it very strange indeed that one so coolly acknowledges the existence of those abuses, as if it were a question of something that lay beyond reach or competence.

  183. 183

    I shall attempt to set out the causes of this.

  184. 184

    In general the conveying of bad tidings is already something unpleasant, and it seems indeed as if, of the unfavorable impression they cause, something remains clinging to the one to whose lot the dreary task of imparting such tidings has fallen.

  185. 185

    Now when this alone would already be reason enough for some, against their better knowledge, to deny the existence of something unfavorable, how much the more is this the case when one runs the danger not only of bringing upon one's own neck the disfavor that seems to be, once and for all, the lot of the bearer of bad reports, but also of being regarded as the cause of the unfavorable condition that one, in duty, discloses.

  186. 186

    The Government of the Dutch Indies writes by preference to its masters in the motherland that everything is going as one would wish.

  187. 187

    The residents gladly report this to the Government.

  188. 188

    The assistant residents, who themselves receive from their controllers hardly any but favorable reports, in their turn likewise send the residents no unpleasant tidings if they can help it.

  189. 189

    Out of this there is born, in the official and written handling of affairs, an artificial optimism, in contradiction not only with the truth, but also with the very opinion of those optimists themselves, as soon as they handle the same matters by word of mouth, and — stranger still! — often even in contradiction with their own written reports.

  190. 190

    I could cite many examples of reports that extol to the utmost the favorable condition of a residency, yet at the same time, above all where the figures speak, give themselves the lie.

  191. 191

    These examples would, were the matter not too serious on account of its eventual consequences, give occasion for laughter and mockery, and one stands astonished at the naïveté with which, in such a case, the grossest untruths are often maintained and accepted, even though the writer himself, a few sentences further on, offers the very weapons by which those untruths are to be combated.

  192. 192

    I shall confine myself to a single example, which I could multiply with very many.

  193. 193

    Among the papers that lie before me, I find the annual report of a residency.

  194. 194

    The resident praises the trade that flourishes there, and asserts that throughout the whole region the greatest prosperity and activity are to be observed.

  195. 195

    A little further on, however, speaking of the slender means at his disposal for checking smuggling, he wishes at once to remove the unfavorable impression that would be made upon the Government by the notion that, this being so, much Import Duty is being evaded in that residency. "No," he says, "on that score one need not be concerned!

  196. 196

    Little or nothing is brought into my residency by stealth, for ... so little business is done in these parts that no one here would risk his capital in trade." I have read a similar report that opened with the words: "in the past year the peace has remained peaceful." Such sentences bear witness indeed to a very restful restfulness, relying on the indulgence of the Government toward everyone who spares it unpleasant tidings, or who, as the term runs, "does not trouble it" with dreary reports!

  197. 197

    Where the population does not increase, this is to be ascribed to the inaccuracy of the censuses of former years.

  198. 198

    Where the taxes do not rise, one makes a merit of it: the intention is, by low assessment, to encourage agriculture, which is just now beginning to develop, and which presently — preferably once the reporter shall have retired — must yield inconceivable fruits.

  199. 199

    Where disorder has occurred that could not be kept hidden, this was the work of a few ill-disposed persons who are no longer to be feared for the future, since a general contentment prevails.

  200. 200

    Where want or famine has thinned the population, this was a consequence of crop failure, of drought, rain, or some such thing, never of misgovernment.

  201. 201

    The memorandum of Havelaar's predecessor, in which he "ascribed the exodus of people from the district of Parang-Koedjang to far-reaching abuse," lies before me.

  202. 202

    This memorandum was unofficial, and contained points on which that official had to speak with the resident of Bantam.

  203. 203

    But in vain did Havelaar search the archive for a sign that his predecessor had frankly called that same matter by its true name in an open official dispatch.

  204. 204

    In short, the official reports of the officers to the Governor's office, and thus also the reports founded on them to the Government in the motherland, are, for the greatest and most important part: untrue.

  205. 205

    I know that this charge is a weighty one, yet I maintain it, and feel myself fully able to support it with proofs.

  206. 206

    Whoever may be vexed at this unveiled utterance of my opinion, let him consider how many millions of treasure and how many human lives would have been spared to England, had the eyes of the nation there been opened in time to the true state of affairs in British India, and how great a gratitude would have been owed to the man who had shown the courage to be the bearer of evil tidings, before it was too late to mend what was amiss by a less bloody means than has now indeed become necessary.

  207. 207

    I said that I could support my charge.

  208. 208

    Where it is needful, I shall show that famine often prevailed in regions that were praised as models of prosperity, and that more than once a population reported as quiet and content stood on the point of bursting out in fury.

  209. 209

    It is not my intention to furnish these proofs in this book, though I trust that no one will lay it from his hand without believing that they exist.

  210. 210

    For the moment I confine myself to one more single example of the ridiculous optimism of which I have spoken, an example that by everyone — whether or not he be acquainted with the affairs of the Indies — will easily be understood.

  211. 211

    Every resident submits a monthly return of the rice that has been imported into his district, or sent out from it to elsewhere.

  212. 212

    In this return that transport is split into two parts, according as it is confined to Java itself or extends further afield.

  213. 213

    When one now attends to the quantity of rice which, according to those returns, has been carried over from residencies on Java to residencies on Java, one will find that this quantity amounts to many thousands of piculs more than the rice which, according to the same returns, has been imported into residencies on Java from residencies on Java.

  214. 214

    I now pass over in silence what one is to think of the perspicacity of the Government that accepts and publishes such returns, and will only draw the reader's attention to the bearing of this falsehood.

  215. 215

    The percentage reward paid to European and native officers for products that must be sold in Europe had so thrust the cultivation of rice into the background that in some regions a famine prevailed which could not be conjured away from the eyes of the nation.

  216. 216

    I have said already that orders were then given not to let matters again come to such a pass.

  217. 217

    Among the many offshoots of these orders were also the returns I have mentioned of rice exported and imported, so that the Government might keep its eye continually on the ebb and flow of that foodstuff.

  218. 218

    Export from a residency represents prosperity; Import: a relative want.

  219. 219

    When one now examines and compares those returns, it appears from them that rice is everywhere so abundant that all the residencies together export more rice than is imported into all the residencies together. I repeat that there is here no question of export overseas, the return of which is kept separately.

  220. 220

    The upshot of this is therefore the absurd proposition: that there is more rice on Java than there is rice.

  221. 221

    That, surely, is prosperity!

  222. 222

    I said already that the urge to impart never any but good reports to the Government would pass over into the ridiculous, were not the consequences of all this so sorrowful.

  223. 223

    For what improvement of much that is amiss is to be hoped, when there exists a fixed and predetermined intention to bend and twist everything in the reports to the administration?

  224. 224

    What, for example, is to be expected of a population that, gentle and meek by nature, has for years upon years complained of oppression, when it sees one resident before, another after, retire on leave or pension, or be called away to another post, without anything having been done toward redress of the grievances under which it goes bowed!

  225. 225

    Must not the bent spring at last fly back?

  226. 226

    Must not the discontent so long suppressed — suppressed, that one might go on denying it! — at last break over into fury, into despair, into frenzy?

  227. 227

    Does there not lie a Jacquerie at the end of this road?

  228. 228

    And where will the officers then be, who for years succeeded one another without it ever once entering their minds that there exists something higher than the "favor of the Government?" Something higher than the "contentment of the Governor-General?" Where will they then be, the writers of feeble reports who blinded the eyes of the Administration with their untruths?

  229. 229

    Will those who formerly lacked the courage to set down a resolute word on paper then fly to arms and keep the Dutch possessions for the Netherlands?

  230. 230

    Will they give back to the Netherlands the treasures that will be needed for the quelling of revolt, for the prevention of upheaval?

  231. 231

    Will they give back life to the thousands who fell there through their fault?

  232. 232

    And those officials, those controllers and residents, are not the most guilty.

  233. 233

    It is the Government itself that, as though struck with an inconceivable blindness, encourages, draws forth, and rewards the submitting of favorable reports. This is above all the case where there is question of oppression of the population by native Chiefs.

  234. 234

    By many this protection of the Chiefs is ascribed to the ignoble calculation that they, being obliged to display pomp and splendor in order to exert upon the population the influence the Government needs to keep its own authority standing, would for that purpose have to enjoy a far higher remuneration than is now the case, if one did not leave them the liberty of making up the shortfall by unlawful disposal over the possessions and the labor of the people.

  235. 235

    However this may be, the Government proceeds only reluctantly to the applying of the regulations that are supposed to protect the Javanese against extortion and robbery.

  236. 236

    For the most part one knows how to find, in unverifiable reasons of statecraft often plucked from the air, a cause for sparing this Regent or that Chief, and it is therefore in the Indies an opinion grown proverbial that the Government would sooner dismiss ten residents than one Regent.

  237. 237

    Those pretended political reasons too — if they rest on anything at all — usually rest on false returns, since every resident has an interest in magnifying the influence of his Regents over the population, in order to shelter behind it should remarks later one day be made about too great an indulgence toward those chiefs.

  238. 238

    I now pass over the abominable hypocrisy of the humane-sounding regulations — and of the oaths! — that protect the Javanese against arbitrary power ... on paper, and I ask the reader to recall how Havelaar, in repeating those oaths, conveyed something that suggested contempt. For the moment I will only point to the difficulty of the position of the man who, quite otherwise than by virtue of a spoken formula, held himself bound to his duty.

  239. 239

    And for him this difficulty was greater still than it would have been for some others, because his temper was gentle, wholly at odds with that perspicacity which the reader will by now have come to know as fairly sharp.

  240. 240

    He had therefore not only to struggle with fear of men or with concern for career and advancement, nor even only with the duties he had to fulfill as husband and father of a household: he had to overcome an enemy in his own heart.

  241. 241

    He could not see suffering without suffering himself, and it would carry me too far were I to cite the instances of how he always, even where he had been wronged and insulted, defended an opponent's cause against the opponent himself.

  242. 242

    He told Duclari and Verbrugge how in his youth he had found something appealing in the duel with the sabre — which was the truth — yet he did not add how, after wounding his adversary, he would commonly weep, and tend his former enemy like a sister of charity until the wound had healed.

  243. 243

    I could relate how at Natal he took into his own keeping the chain-gang convict who had fired at him, spoke to the man kindly, had him fed, and granted him more freedom than all the others, because he believed he could perceive that this condemned man's bitterness was the consequence of too harsh a sentence passed elsewhere. Commonly the gentleness of his nature was either denied or thought ridiculous.

  244. 244

    Denied by those who confused his heart with his mind. Thought ridiculous by those who could not grasp how a sensible man would take pains to rescue a fly that had got caught in the web of a spider.

  245. 245

    Denied again by everyone — save Tine — who afterward heard him rail at those "stupid creatures" and at the "stupid nature" that made such creatures. But there was yet another way to bring him down from the pedestal upon which the people around him — whether they loved him or not — were obliged to set him.

  246. 246

    "Yes, he is witty, but ... there is a flightiness in his wit." Or: "he is sensible, but ... he does not use his good sense well." Or: "yes, he is kindhearted, but ... he makes a show of it!"

  247. 247

    For his wit, for his good sense, I take no one's part.

  248. 248

    But his heart?

  249. 249

    Poor struggling little flies that he rescued when he was entirely alone, will you defend that heart against the charge of affectation?

  250. 250

    But you have flown away, and gave no thought to Havelaar, you who could not have known that he would one day have need of your testimony!

  251. 251

    Was it affectation in Havelaar when at Natal he leapt after a dog — the creature was called Sappho — into the mouth of the river, because he feared the still-young animal could not swim well enough to avoid the sharks that are so plentiful there?

  252. 252

    I find such a show of kindheartedness harder to believe in than the kindheartedness itself.

  253. 253

    I call upon you, you, the many who have known Havelaar — provided you are not stiffened by winter cold and dead ... like the rescued flies, or dried out by the heat over yonder beneath the equator! — I call upon you to bear witness to his heart, all of you who have known him!

  254. 254

    Now above all I call upon you with confidence, since you no longer need to search out where the cord must be hooked in to drag him down from whatever trifling height it may be.

  255. 255

    Meanwhile, however incongruous it may seem, I shall give space here to a few lines from his own hand, which perhaps make such testimonies unnecessary.

  256. 256

    Max was once far, far away from wife and child.

  257. 257

    He had been obliged to leave them behind in the Indies, and found himself in Germany.

  258. 258

    With the quickness I credit to him — though I do not take it under my protection should anyone wish to attack it — he made himself master of the language of the country where he had spent a few months.

  259. 259

    Here are those lines, which at the same time sketch the intimacy of the bond that attached him to his own.

  260. 260

    — My child, there strikes the ninth hour, hark!

  261. 261

    The night wind whispers, and the air grows cool, too cool for you perhaps: your little brow is glowing! All day long you have played so wildly, and you must be tired — come, your bed awaits.

  262. 262

    — Ah, Mother, let me stay a little longer! It is so soft to rest here ... and over there, on my mat indoors, I fall asleep at once, and do not even know what I am dreaming!

  263. 263

    Here I can tell you right away what I am dreaming.

  264. 264

    And ask what my dream means ... hark, what was that?

  265. 265

    — It was a coconut that fell. — Does that hurt the coconut?

  266. 266

    — I think not. They say the fruit, the nut, has no feeling.

  267. 267

    — But a flower, does it not feel either?

  268. 268

    — No, they say it does not feel. — Then why, Mother, when yesterday I broke the pukul ampat, did you say: it hurts the flower?

  269. 269

    — My child, the pukul ampat was so lovely; you tore the tender little petals roughly in two, and that grieved me for the poor flower. Even though the flower itself felt nothing, I felt it for the flower, because it was lovely.

  270. 270

    — But, Mother, are you lovely too?

  271. 271

    — No, my child, I think not.

  272. 272

    — But you have feeling?

  273. 273

    — Yes, people have it ... though not all alike.

  274. 274

    — And can anything hurt you? Does it hurt you when my little head rests so heavily in your lap?

  275. 275

    — No, that does not hurt me!

  276. 276

    — And, Mother, do I ... do I have feeling?

  277. 277

    — Surely! Remember how you, having once stumbled against a stone, wounded your little hand, and wept.

  278. 278

    You wept too when Saudien told you that up on the hills yonder a little lamb fell deep down into a ravine, and died. You wept a long while then ... that was feeling.

  279. 279

    — But, Mother, is feeling then pain? — Yes, often!

  280. 280

    But ... not always, sometimes not! You know, when your little sister grabs you by the hair, and crowing presses her little face close to yours, then you laugh for joy — that is feeling too.

  281. 281

    — And then my little sister ... she cries so often, is that from pain? Has she feeling too, then?

  282. 282

    — Perhaps, my child, but we do not know it, because she, so small, cannot yet say so.

  283. 283

    — But, Mother ... hark, what was that?

  284. 284

    — A stag that lingered too long in the thicket, and now hurries homeward, and seeks rest among other stags that are dear to him.

  285. 285

    — Mother, has such a stag a little sister like me? And a mother too?

  286. 286

    — I do not know, child.

  287. 287

    — That would be sad, if it were not so!

  288. 288

    But, Mother, look ... what is shimmering there in the bush? Look how it hops and dances ... is that a spark?

  289. 289

    — It is a firefly.

  290. 290

    — May I catch it?

  291. 291

    — You may, but the little fly is so delicate, you will surely hurt it, and as soon as you touch it with your fingers all too roughly, the little creature falls ill, and dies, and shines no more.

  292. 292

    — That would be a pity! No, I shall not catch it!

  293. 293

    Look, there it vanished ... no, it is coming this way ...

  294. 294

    I shall not catch it after all! Again it flies away, and is glad that I have not caught it!

  295. 295

    There it flies ... high! High, up above ... what is that, are those also little fireflies up there?

  296. 296

    — Those are the stars.

  297. 297

    — One, and ten, and a thousand!

  298. 298

    How many are there, then?

  299. 299

    — I do not know; the number of the stars no one has yet counted.

  300. 300

    — Tell me, Mother, does He not count the stars either?

  301. 301

    — No, dear child, not even He.

  302. 302

    — Is it far, up there where the stars are?

  303. 303

    — Very far!

  304. 304

    — But do these stars have feeling too?

  305. 305

    And would they, if I touched them with my hand, fall ill at once, and lose their glow, like the little fly? — Look, it is still hovering!

  306. 306

    Tell me, would it hurt the stars too?

  307. 307

    — No, it does not hurt the stars!

  308. 308

    But it is too far for your little hand: you cannot reach so high. — Can He catch the stars with His hand?

  309. 309

    — Not even He: no one can!

  310. 310

    — That is a pity!

  311. 311

    I would so gladly give you one!

  312. 312

    When I am grown, then I will love you so that I can do it. The child fell asleep.

  313. 313

    It dreamed of feeling, of stars that it grasped with its hand ....

  314. 314

    The mother did not sleep for a long while yet!

  315. 315

    Yet she too dreamed, and thought of the one who was far away ...

  316. 316

    Yes, at the risk of seeming incongruous, I have given those lines a place here.

  317. 317

    I wish to let slip no opportunity to make known the man who plays the leading part in my story, so that he may inspire the reader with some interest when, later, dark clouds gather over his head.

The particulars

The text
Max Havelaar, Multatuli. The Novel.
Translation
Public-domain Dutch (Multatuli, d. 1887; published 1860). English translation © 2026 1732 Studios, LLC.
Reading aloud
Digital narration, directed by 1732 Studios.
Words
Every word of the text, by letter.
Data
JSON · Markdown · A guide for agents
Two whoopie pies and a pine. An inside joke.