The Brothers Karamazov 1732 Studios

Russian · Book X — The Boys

VI. Раннее развитие

Precocity

202 sentences · 342 notes

Tap a sentence to open its words.

  1. 1

    "What do you suppose the doctor will tell him?" Kolya rattled out. "What a repulsive mug, though, isn't it?"

    Какhowкак · adverbmodifies думаете
    выyouвы · pronoun, nominative, pluralsubject of думаете
    думаетеdo you supposeдумать · verb, present, indicative, active, second, plural, imperfectivemain verb of the sentence
    чтоwhatчто · pronoun, accusative, neuter, singulardirect object of скажет
    емуhimон · pronoun, dative, masculine, singularindirect object of скажет
    скажетwill tellсказать · verb, future, indicative, active, third, singular, perfectiveclausal complement of думаете
    докторthe doctorдоктор · noun, nominative, masculine, singularsubject of скажет
    скороговоркойin a rapid patterскороговорка · noun, instrumental, feminine, singularoblique complement of проговорил
    проговорилrattled outпроговорить · verb, past, indicative, active, singular, perfectivemain verb of the sentence
    КоляKolyaколя · proper noun, nominative, masculine, singularsubject of проговорил
    какаяwhat aкакой · determiner, nominative, feminine, singulardeterminer of харя (via отвратительная)
    отвратительнаяrepulsiveотвратительный · adjective, nominative, feminine, singularmodifies харя
    однакоthoughоднако · adverbparenthetical modifying харя
    жеstillже · particleintensifies однако
    харяmugхаря · noun, nominative, feminine, singularhead of the exclamation
    неnotне · particlemodifies правда
    правдаtrueправда · adverbhead of tag question не...ли
    лиisn't itли · particleforms tag question with не правда

    не...ли forms a yes/no tag question, like English "isn't it?"

  2. 2

    I can't abide medicine!

  3. 3

    "Ilusha is going to die.

  4. 4

    That seems to me quite certain now," Alyosha answered sadly.

  5. 5

    "Scoundrels!

  6. 6

    Medicine is a scoundrel!

  7. 7

    All the same, I'm glad I've come to know you, Karamazov.

  8. 8

    I've long wanted to know you.

  9. 9

    It's only a pity that we've met under such sad circumstances..."

  10. 10

    Kolya would dearly have liked to say something still warmer, still more expansive, but something seemed to hold him back.

  11. 11

    Alyosha noticed it, smiled, and pressed his hand.

  12. 12

    "I learned to respect you long ago as a rare being," Kolya muttered again, faltering and getting tangled up.

  13. 13

    "I've heard you're a mystic and that you were in the monastery.

  14. 14

    I know you're a mystic, but... that hasn't stopped me.

  15. 15

    Contact with reality will cure you...

  16. 16

    With natures like yours it can't be otherwise."

  17. 17

    "What do you mean by a mystic?

  18. 18

    Cure me of what?" Alyosha asked, a little surprised.

  19. 19

    "Oh, God and all the rest of it."

  20. 20

    "What, do you mean you don't believe in God?"

  21. 21

    "On the contrary, I have nothing against God.

  22. 22

    Of course, God is merely a hypothesis... but... I admit that he is necessary, for the sake of order... for the order of the world and so on... and if he didn't exist, then he would have to be invented," Kolya added, beginning to blush.

  23. 23

    It suddenly struck him that Alyosha might think he was trying to parade his learning and show off what a "big" person he was.

  24. 24

    "But I don't want to parade my learning in front of him at all," Kolya thought with indignation.

  25. 25

    And all at once he felt terribly vexed.

  26. 26

    "I confess I can't bear getting into all these wrangles," he snapped, "after all, one can love mankind even without believing in God, don't you think?

  27. 27

    Voltaire, now, didn't believe in God, yet he loved mankind, didn't he?" ("Again, there I go again!" he thought to himself.)

  28. 28

    "Voltaire did believe in God, only not much, it seems, and he loved mankind not much either, it seems," Alyosha pronounced quietly, with restraint, and quite naturally, as though he were talking with someone his own age, or even older than himself.

  29. 29

    What struck Kolya in particular was this seeming uncertainty of Alyosha's about his own opinion of Voltaire, and the way he seemed to be leaving the question to him, little Kolya, to decide.

  30. 30

    "And have you actually read Voltaire?" Alyosha asked in conclusion.

  31. 31

    "No, it isn't that I've read him exactly... Though I did read 'Candide,' in a Russian translation... an old, hideous translation, a ridiculous one..." ("Again, there I go again!")

  32. 32

    "And you understood it?"

  33. 33

    "Oh yes, all of it... that is... why should you suppose I wouldn't understand it?

  34. 34

    There's a good deal that's bawdy in it, of course...

  35. 35

    I'm quite capable, of course, of grasping that it's a philosophical novel and was written to put across an idea..." Kolya floundered hopelessly by now.

  36. 36

    "I'm a socialist, Karamazov, I'm an incorrigible socialist," he suddenly broke off, apropos of nothing at all.

  37. 37

    "A socialist?" Alyosha laughed. "Why, when did you find the time?

  38. 38

    You're only thirteen, I think?"

  39. 39

    Kolya winced as if he'd been pinched.

  40. 40

    "In the first place, not thirteen but fourteen — fourteen in two weeks," he flared up at once, "and in the second place, I utterly fail to see what my age has to do with it.

  41. 41

    What matters is what my convictions are, not how old I am, isn't that so?"

  42. 42

    "When you're older, you'll see for yourself how much one's age has to do with one's convictions.

  43. 43

    It also seemed to me that you weren't speaking your own words," Alyosha answered modestly and calmly, but Kolya cut him off heatedly.

  44. 44

    "Come now, you want obedience and mysticism.

  45. 45

    You'll grant, for instance, that the Christian faith has served only the rich and the high-born, so as to keep the lower class in bondage, won't you?"

  46. 46

    "Ah, I know where you read that, and somebody certainly put you up to it!" Alyosha exclaimed.

  47. 47

    "Come now, why must it be that I read it?

  48. 48

    And nobody at all put me up to it.

  49. 49

    I'm capable of it on my own... And if you want to know, I'm not against Christ.

  50. 50

    He was an entirely humane personality, and had he lived in our day, he would have joined the revolutionaries outright and might have played a conspicuous part... that's even beyond doubt."

  51. 51

    "Well, where, oh where did you pick all this up!

  52. 52

    What fool have you fallen in with?" Alyosha exclaimed.

  53. 53

    "Come now, there's no hiding the truth.

  54. 54

    It's true I happen to talk a good deal with Mr. Rakitin, but... old Belinsky used to say it too, so they tell me."

  55. 55

    "Belinsky?

  56. 56

    I don't recall it.

  57. 57

    He never wrote that anywhere."

  58. 58

    "He may not have written it, but he said it, so they tell me.

  59. 59

    I heard it from a certain... well, the devil..."

  60. 60

    "And have you read Belinsky?"

  61. 61

    "Well, you see... no... I haven't quite read him, but... the passage about Tatyana, about why she didn't go off with Onegin, that I did read."

  62. 62

    "What do you mean, didn't go off with Onegin?

  63. 63

    Do you mean you already... understand that?"

  64. 64

    "Come now, you seem to be taking me for the boy Smurov," Kolya bared his teeth in an irritated grin.

  65. 65

    "But please, don't imagine that I'm such a great revolutionary.

  66. 66

    Very often I don't agree with Mr. Rakitin at all.

  67. 67

    If I bring up Tatyana, it isn't that I'm for the emancipation of women in the least.

  68. 68

    I hold that woman is a subordinate creature and must obey.

  69. 69

    Les femmes tricottent, as Napoleon said," Kolya smirked for some reason, "and on this point, at least, I entirely share the conviction of that pseudo-great man."

  70. 70

    I also hold, for instance, that to run off to America away from one's fatherland is base — worse than base, it's stupid.

  71. 71

    Why go to America, when here at home one can do so much good for mankind?

  72. 72

    Precisely now.

  73. 73

    A whole mass of fruitful activity.

  74. 74

    That's just what I answered."

  75. 75

    "What do you mean, answered?

  76. 76

    To whom?

  77. 77

    Has somebody actually invited you to America already?"

  78. 78

    "I confess they tried to talk me into it, but I refused.

  79. 79

    This is between us, of course, Karamazov — do you hear, not a word to anyone.

  80. 80

    This is for you alone.

  81. 81

    I've no wish at all to fall into the clutches of the Third Section and take lessons by the Chain Bridge — You'll remember the building by the Chain Bridge!

  82. 82

    You remember it?

  83. 83

    Splendid!

  84. 84

    What are you laughing at?

  85. 85

    Surely you don't think I've made the whole thing up?" ("And what if he finds out that the one and only thing I've got in my father's cabinet is this single issue of 'The Bell,' and that I've read nothing more of it than that?" Kolya thought in passing, but with a shudder.)

  86. 86

    "Oh no, I'm not laughing, and I don't in the least think you've lied to me.

  87. 87

    That's just the point, that I don't think it, because all of this, alas, is the plain truth!

  88. 88

    But tell me, have you read your Pushkin, 'Onegin' that is... You were speaking just now about Tatyana?"

  89. 89

    "No, I haven't read it yet, but I mean to.

  90. 90

    I'm without prejudices, Karamazov.

  91. 91

    I want to hear out both the one side and the other.

  92. 92

    Why do you ask?"

  93. 93

    "No reason."

  94. 94

    "Tell me, Karamazov, do you despise me terribly?" Kolya snapped suddenly and drew himself up to his full height before Alyosha, as if striking a pose.

  95. 95

    "Do me the kindness, no beating about the bush."

  96. 96

    "Despise you?" Alyosha looked at him in astonishment.

  97. 97

    "Why, whatever for?

  98. 98

    I only feel sad that so fine a nature as yours, one that hasn't even begun to live, should already be warped by all this coarse nonsense."

  99. 99

    "Don't trouble yourself about my nature," Kolya interrupted, not without self-satisfaction, "but that I'm suspicious — that's true enough.

  100. 100

    Stupidly suspicious, crudely suspicious.

  101. 101

    You smirked just now, and it seemed to me as if you were somehow..."

  102. 102

    "Ah, I was smirking at something else entirely.

  103. 103

    You see what I was smirking at: I recently read a remark by some German from abroad who'd been living in Russia, about our students of the present day: 'Show a Russian schoolboy,' he writes, 'a map of the starry sky that he'd had no notion of until then, and the next day he'll hand it back to you corrected.'

  104. 104

    No knowledge whatever and a boundless conceit — that's what the German meant to say about the Russian schoolboy."

  105. 105

    "Ah, but that's perfectly true!" Kolya suddenly roared with laughter. "Verissimo, exactly right!

  106. 106

    Bravo, German!

  107. 107

    And yet the Finn missed the good side of it, don't you think?

  108. 108

    Conceit — never mind that, that comes from being young, it'll right itself, if it even needs to right itself at all — but on the other hand there's an independent spirit from almost the cradle, on the other hand a boldness of thought and conviction, and not the spirit of their sausage-eating servility before authority... But all the same the German put it well!

  109. 109

    Bravo, German!

  110. 110

    Though all the same the Germans ought to be throttled.

  111. 111

    Let them be strong in the sciences over there, but all the same they ought to be throttled..."

  112. 112

    "But why throttle them?" Alyosha smiled.

  113. 113

    "Well, I made it up, maybe, I grant you that.

  114. 114

    Sometimes I'm a terrible child, and when I'm glad about something I can't hold myself in and I'm ready to spout any old rubbish.

  115. 115

    Listen, though, the two of us are standing here gabbling about trifles, while that doctor in there has got stuck for ages over something.

  116. 116

    Though perhaps in there he's examining 'mamma' too, and that legless Ninochka.

  117. 117

    You know, I took a liking to that Ninochka.

  118. 118

    She suddenly whispered to me as I was leaving: 'Why didn't you come sooner?'

  119. 119

    And in such a voice, with such reproach!

  120. 120

    I think she's terribly kind and pitiable."

  121. 121

    "Yes, yes!

  122. 122

    Once you start coming, you'll see what sort of creature he is.

  123. 123

    It does you a great deal of good to get to know creatures like this — it teaches you how to value things, and much else besides, which you learn precisely from such acquaintance," Alyosha remarked warmly.

  124. 124

    "It will remake you better than anything else."

  125. 125

    "Oh, how I reproach myself and curse myself for not having come sooner!" Kolya exclaimed with bitter feeling.

  126. 126

    "Yes, it's a great pity.

  127. 127

    You saw for yourself what a joyful impression you made on the poor little fellow!

  128. 128

    And how he wore himself out waiting for you!"

  129. 129

    "Don't tell me that!

  130. 130

    You're rubbing salt in the wound.

  131. 131

    But I deserve it: I didn't come out of vanity, out of a selfish vanity and a base craving to dominate, which I've been unable to shake off my whole life, though all my life I keep wrestling with myself.

  132. 132

    I see it now — in a great many ways I'm a scoundrel, Karamazov."

  133. 133

    "No, you have a charming nature, even if a warped one, and I understand only too well why you could have had such an influence on that noble and morbidly sensitive boy!" Alyosha answered ardently.

  134. 134

    "And it's you who says this to me!" cried Kolya. "Just imagine, I thought — several times already, even now that I'm here, I thought — that you despised me!"

  135. 135

    "If only you knew how much I value your opinion!"

  136. 136

    "But can you really be so suspicious?

  137. 137

    At your age!

  138. 138

    Well, just imagine — in that very room, watching you while you were telling your story, I thought to myself that you must be very suspicious."

  139. 139

    "You actually thought that?

  140. 140

    What an eye you have, though — you see, you see!

  141. 141

    I'd lay a wager it was at the point where I was telling about the goose.

  142. 142

    Right at that point I got it into my head that you deeply despised me for being in such a hurry to show off as a fine fellow, and I suddenly even hated you for it and began talking nonsense.

  143. 143

    Then I imagined (this was just now, here) — at the point where I said, "If God did not exist, he would have to be invented" — that I was being too quick to flaunt my education, all the more so since I'd read that phrase in a book.

  144. 144

    But I swear to you, I was hurrying to show off not out of conceit, but just so, I don't know why, out of joy — by God, as if out of sheer joy… though it's a deeply shameful trait, when a person throws himself on everyone's neck out of joy.

  145. 145

    I know that.

  146. 146

    But now, on the other hand, I'm convinced that you don't despise me — I made the whole thing up myself.

  147. 147

    Oh, Karamazov, I'm deeply unhappy.

  148. 148

    Sometimes I imagine God knows what — that everyone is laughing at me, the whole world, and then I'm simply ready to wipe out the entire order of things."

  149. 149

    "And you torment those around you," Alyosha said with a smile.

  150. 150

    "And I torment those around me, especially my mother.

  151. 151

    Karamazov, tell me, am I being very ridiculous just now?"

  152. 152

    "Don't even think about that — don't think about it at all!" cried Alyosha.

  153. 153

    "And anyway, what does ridiculous mean?

  154. 154

    How many times does a man turn out to be, or merely seem, ridiculous?

  155. 155

    Besides, nowadays nearly all gifted people are terribly afraid of being ridiculous, and that's what makes them miserable.

  156. 156

    The only thing that surprises me is that you began to feel this so early — though, for that matter, I've long been noticing it, and not in you alone.

  157. 157

    Nowadays even children, almost, have begun to suffer from it.

  158. 158

    It's practically a madness.

  159. 159

    The devil has taken on flesh in this vanity and crept into the whole generation — the devil, precisely," Alyosha added, not smiling at all, as Kolya, who had been staring point-blank at him, had supposed he would.

  160. 160

    "You're like everyone else," Alyosha concluded, "that is, like a great many people, only one shouldn't be like everyone else — that's the thing."

  161. 161

    "Even in spite of the fact that everyone is like that?"

  162. 162

    "Yes, in spite of the fact that everyone is like that.

  163. 163

    You be the one who isn't.

  164. 164

    And you really aren't like everyone else: just now you weren't ashamed to confess to something bad, and even to something ridiculous.

  165. 165

    And these days who ever admits to that?

  166. 166

    No one — people have even stopped feeling any need for self-reproach.

  167. 167

    Be unlike everyone else, then; even if you alone remained unlike them, still be unlike them."

  168. 168

    "Splendid!

  169. 169

    I wasn't mistaken in you.

  170. 170

    You know how to comfort a person.

  171. 171

    Oh, how I longed to come to you, Karamazov, how long I've been seeking a meeting with you!

  172. 172

    Did you really think about me too?

  173. 173

    Just now you said that you'd thought about me too?"

  174. 174

    "Yes, I'd heard about you, and I'd thought about you too… and even if it was partly vanity that made you ask me this just now, that's nothing."

  175. 175

    "You know, Karamazov, our talk is rather like a declaration of love," Kolya said in a voice gone somehow limp and bashful.

  176. 176

    "That isn't ridiculous, is it — not ridiculous?"

  177. 177

    "Not ridiculous at all, and even if it were, that's nothing, because it's good," Alyosha said with a bright smile.

  178. 178

    "And you know, Karamazov, you must admit that even you yourself feel a little embarrassed with me now… I can see it in your eyes," Kolya said with a sly grin, yet with a kind of almost happy look.

  179. 179

    "Embarrassed about what?"

  180. 180

    "Then why did you blush?"

  181. 181

    "Why, it's you who made me blush!" Alyosha laughed, and indeed he went quite red.

  182. 182

    "Well, yes, I am a little embarrassed, God knows why, I don't know why…" he muttered, almost flustered now.

  183. 183

    "Oh, how I love you and prize you at this moment, precisely because you too feel embarrassed about something with me!

  184. 184

    Because you're exactly like me!" Kolya exclaimed in utter rapture.

  185. 185

    His cheeks were burning, his eyes were shining.

  186. 186

    "Listen, Kolya, among other things, you're going to be a very unhappy man in life," Alyosha said suddenly, for some reason.

  187. 187

    "I know, I know.

  188. 188

    How is it you know all this beforehand!" Kolya at once confirmed.

  189. 189

    "But on the whole, all the same, you'll bless life."

  190. 190

    "Exactly!

  191. 191

    Hurrah!

  192. 192

    You're a prophet!

  193. 193

    Oh, we shall get on together, Karamazov.

  194. 194

    You know, what delights me most of all is that you treat me completely as an equal.

  195. 195

    But we're not equals, no, not equals — you're higher!

  196. 196

    Still, we shall get on together.

  197. 197

    You know, this whole past month I've been telling myself: "Either he and I will come together at once as friends forever, or from the very first we'll part as enemies to the grave!"

  198. 198

    "And saying so, you already loved me, of course!" Alyosha laughed merrily.

  199. 199

    "I did, I loved you terribly, I loved you and dreamed about you!

  200. 200

    And how is it you know everything beforehand?

  201. 201

    Ah, here's the doctor.

  202. 202

    Lord, what's he going to say — look at his face!"

The particulars

The text
Братья Карамазовы, Fyodor Dostoevsky. Book X — The Boys.
Translation
Public-domain Russian (Dostoevsky, d. 1881). Translation © 2026 1732 Studios.
Words
Every word of the text, by letter.
Data
JSON · Markdown · A guide for agents
Two whoopie pies and a pine. An inside joke.