The Brothers Karamazov 1732 Studios

Russian · Book V — Pro and Contra

VII. «С умным человеком и поговорить любопытно»

"It's Always Worth While Speaking to a Clever Man"

179 sentences · 362 notes

Tap a sentence to open its words.

  1. 1

    And speak he did.

    Даandда · particlelinks the coordination
    иindeedи · particlemodifies говорил
    говорилtalkedговорить · verb, past, indicative, active, singular, imperfectivemain verb of the sentence
    тожеtooтоже · adverbmodifies говорил
  2. 2

    Meeting Fyodor Pavlovich in the hall the moment he came in, he suddenly shouted at him, waving his arms: "I'm going up to my own room, not in to you — goodbye," and walked past, even trying not to glance at his father.

  3. 3

    Very likely the old man was simply too hateful to him at that moment, but such an unceremonious display of hostility came as a surprise even to Fyodor Pavlovich.

  4. 4

    And the old man had evidently meant, in fact, to tell him something in a hurry — that was the very reason he had come out on purpose to meet him in the hall; on hearing such a civility, however, he stopped in silence and, with a mocking look, followed his little son with his eyes up the stairs toward the attic, until the young man had vanished from sight.

  5. 5

    "What's the matter with him?"

  6. 6

    he quickly asked Smerdyakov, who had come in behind Ivan Fyodorovich.

  7. 7

    "Cross about something, sir — who can make them out," the man muttered evasively.

  8. 8

    "Well, the devil take him!

  9. 9

    Let him be cross!

  10. 10

    Bring the samovar and then clear out yourself, and be quick about it.

  11. 11

    Anything new?"

  12. 12

    Here began the very questions of the kind Smerdyakov had just been complaining of to Ivan Fyodorovich — all of them, that is, about the expected visitor — and we shall pass these questions over here.

  13. 13

    Within half an hour the house was locked up, and the deranged old man paced the rooms alone, in tremulous anticipation that at any moment the five agreed-upon knocks would sound, now and then peering into the dark windows and seeing nothing in them but the night.

  14. 14

    It was already very late, and Ivan Fyodorovich still lay awake, turning things over.

  15. 15

    He went to bed late that night, around two o'clock.

  16. 16

    But we shall not set down the whole course of his thoughts, nor is it the moment for us to enter into that soul: that soul will have its turn.

  17. 17

    And even if we did try to convey something of it, it would be very hard to do, because they were not thoughts at all, but something very indefinite, and — above all — too agitated.

  18. 18

    He felt himself that he had lost all his bearings.

  19. 19

    He was tormented, too, by various strange and almost wholly unexpected desires; for instance, sometime after midnight he was suddenly seized by an urgent, unbearable craving to go downstairs, unbolt the door, cross to the lodge, and beat Smerdyakov — yet had you asked him what for, he himself could not have set out a single reason precisely, except perhaps that this lackey had become as hateful to him as the gravest offender one could find anywhere in the world.

  20. 20

    On the other hand, more than once that night his soul was overcome by a kind of inexplicable and humiliating timidity, from which he — he felt it — even seemed all at once to lose his physical strength.

  21. 21

    His head ached and swam.

  22. 22

    Something hateful gnawed at his soul, as though he were about to take revenge on someone.

  23. 23

    He hated even Alyosha, recalling the conversation he had had with him earlier that day; at moments he hated himself intensely as well.

  24. 24

    Of Katerina Ivanovna he had almost forgotten even to think — something he marveled at greatly afterward, the more so since he himself remembered clearly how only yesterday morning, when he had boasted so grandly at Katerina Ivanovna's that he would leave for Moscow tomorrow, he had whispered to himself at that very moment, deep down: "But that's nonsense — you won't go, and it won't be so easy for you to tear yourself away as you're swaggering now."

  25. 25

    Recalling that night long afterward, Ivan Fyodorovich would remember with peculiar disgust how he suddenly, every so often, would get up from the sofa and softly, as though terribly afraid of being spied upon, open the door, go out onto the stairs, and listen down into the lower rooms — listen to Fyodor Pavlovich stirring and pacing about down below — listen for a long while, five minutes at a stretch, with a strange sort of curiosity, holding his breath, his heart pounding; and why he kept doing all this, why he was listening, he himself, of course, did not know.

  26. 26

    That "act" he would all his life afterward call "vile," and all his life he reckoned it, deep within himself, in the innermost recesses of his soul, the basest act of his whole life.

  27. 27

    Toward Fyodor Pavlovich himself, in those moments, he felt no hatred whatever — he was merely, for some reason, curious with all his might: how was he moving about down there, what could he be doing now in his rooms, and he tried to guess and picture how the old man must be peering into the dark windows down below, then suddenly stopping in the middle of the room and waiting, waiting — to see whether anyone would knock.

  28. 28

    Twice Ivan Fyodorovich went out onto the stairs for this occupation.

  29. 29

    When everything had fallen quiet and Fyodor Pavlovich too had at last lain down, around two o'clock, Ivan Fyodorovich also lay down, firmly resolved to fall asleep as quickly as possible, since he felt himself terribly worn out.

  30. 30

    And so indeed he did: he fell asleep all at once, soundly, and slept without dreams, but woke early, around seven o'clock, when day had already broken.

  31. 31

    Opening his eyes, he suddenly felt within himself, to his own astonishment, a surge of some extraordinary energy; he sprang up quickly and dressed quickly, then dragged out his trunk and, without delay, began hurriedly packing it.

  32. 32

    His linen, as it happened, had all come back from the laundress only yesterday morning.

  33. 33

    Ivan Fyodorovich even smiled at the thought that everything had fallen out so neatly, that there was nothing to hold up his sudden departure.

  34. 34

    And his departure really was turning out to be a sudden one.

  35. 35

    Although Ivan Fyodorovich had said yesterday (to Katerina Ivanovna, to Alyosha, and then to Smerdyakov) that he would leave tomorrow, yet when he had gone to bed the night before, he remembered very well that at that moment he had not even been thinking of leaving — or at least had had no idea whatever that, waking in the morning, his very first move would be to rush to pack his trunk.

  36. 36

    At last the trunk and the bag were ready: it was already getting on toward nine o'clock when Marfa Ignatyevna came up to him with her usual daily question: "Where will you be pleased to take your tea — in your room, or will you come down?" Ivan Fyodorovich came down, his look almost cheerful, though there was about him, in his words and gestures, something as it were scattered and hurried.

  37. 37

    Having greeted his father amiably and even asked after his health with particular attention, he announced, without however waiting for his parent to finish answering, all at once that within the hour he was leaving for Moscow, for good, and asked that the horses be sent for.

  38. 38

    The old man heard the news without the slightest surprise, and, with marked impropriety, quite forgot to grieve over his little son's departure; instead he suddenly fell into an extraordinary bustle, having recalled, just in the nick of time, a pressing piece of business of his own.

  39. 39

    "Ah, you!

  40. 40

    What a fellow!

  41. 41

    You didn't say so yesterday… well, never mind, we'll settle it now too.

  42. 42

    Do me a great kindness, my own dear boy — stop off at Chermashnya.

  43. 43

    Why, from the Volovya station you've only to turn left, a mere dozen versts or so, and there it is — Chermashnya."

  44. 44

    "For pity's sake, I can't: it's eighty versts to the railway, and the train leaves the station for Moscow at seven in the evening — just exactly time enough to catch it."

  45. 45

    "You'll catch it tomorrow, or the day after — but today turn off to Chermashnya.

  46. 46

    What does it cost you to set your father's mind at ease!

  47. 47

    If I weren't tied up with business here, I'd have dashed over long ago myself, because the matter there is urgent and pressing, but just now my time isn't my own…

  48. 48

    You see, there's that copse of mine over there, on two plots, at Begichevo and at Dyachkino, on the wastelands.

  49. 49

    The Maslovs — the old man and his son, the merchants — are offering only eight thousand for the timber, and only last year a buyer turned up who'd give twelve, but he wasn't a local man, and there's the rub.

  50. 50

    Because the local men have no market now: the Maslovs throw their weight around — father and son, men worth a hundred thousand — they set the price and you take it, and not one of the locals dares to bid against them.

  51. 51

    But the Ilyinsky priest suddenly wrote here last Thursday that Gorstkin had arrived — a petty trader too, I know him — only the precious thing about it is that he's not a local man but from Pogrebovo, which means he's not afraid of the Maslovs, because he's not from here.

  52. 52

    Eleven thousand, he says, I'll give for the copse — do you hear?

  53. 53

    And he'll only be here, the priest writes, another week all told.

  54. 54

    So if you'd go over and come to terms with him…"

  55. 55

    "Then write to the priest, and he'll come to terms."

  56. 56

    "He can't do it — that's the trouble.

  57. 57

    That priest hasn't an eye for it.

  58. 58

    A heart of gold, the man — I'd hand him twenty thousand this minute without a receipt, to keep for me — but he hasn't an eye for anything, it's as if he weren't a man at all; a crow could cheat him.

  59. 59

    And yet he's an educated man, just imagine.

  60. 60

    This Gorstkin looks like a peasant, in a blue full-skirted coat, only in character he's a thorough scoundrel — and that's just where the trouble lies for all of us: he lies, that's the rub.

  61. 61

    Sometimes he tells such lies you can only wonder what on earth he's at.

  62. 62

    Two years ago he lied that his wife had died and that he'd already married another, and none of it was so, just imagine: his wife never died at all, she's alive even now and gives him a thrashing once every three days.

  63. 63

    So now too one has to find out whether he's lying or telling the truth when he says he wants to buy and will give eleven thousand."

  64. 64

    "But I can do nothing about it either — I've no eye for it myself."

  65. 65

    "Stop, wait — you'll do, you will, because I'll tell you all his marks, Gorstkin's, I've had dealings with him a long time now.

  66. 66

    See: you have to watch his beard; his beard is a little reddish thing, mean and thin.

  67. 67

    If the beard trembles while he talks and works himself up — well and good, he's telling the truth, he means business; but if he strokes his beard with his left hand and chuckles to himself — then it means he wants to swindle you, he's playing tricks.

  68. 68

    Never look him in the eyes — you'll make out nothing by his eyes, murky water, the rogue — watch the beard.

  69. 69

    I'll give you a note to him, and you show it.

  70. 70

    He's Gorstkin, only he isn't Gorstkin but Lyagavy — but don't you tell him he's Lyagavy, he'll take offense.

  71. 71

    If you come to terms with him and see it's all right, write here at once.

  72. 72

    Just write this and no more: 'He's not lying.'

  73. 73

    Hold out for eleven; you may come down one thousand, no more.

  74. 74

    Just think: eight and eleven — three thousand difference.

  75. 75

    Those three thousand are as good as found for me — when will you ever get a buyer, and I need the money desperately.

  76. 76

    Let me know it's serious, and then I'll dash over there myself and finish it off — I'll snatch the time somehow.

  77. 77

    But what's the use of my galloping over there now, if your dad's made the whole thing up?

  78. 78

    Well, are you going or not?"

  79. 79

    "Eh, I've no time, spare me."

  80. 80

    "Eh, do your father this favor — I won't forget it!

  81. 81

    You've none of you any heart, that's what!

  82. 82

    What's a day or two to you?

  83. 83

    Where are you off to now — Venice?

  84. 84

    Your Venice won't fall to pieces in a couple of days.

  85. 85

    I'd have sent Alyoshka, only what does Alyoshka know about such matters?

  86. 86

    It's solely because you're a clever man — don't I see it?

  87. 87

    You don't deal in timber, but you've got an eye.

  88. 88

    All that's needed here is to see whether the man's talking in earnest or not.

  89. 89

    I tell you, watch the beard: if the little beard trembles — then he's in earnest."

  90. 90

    "So you're shoving me off to that cursed Chermashnya yourself, are you?"

  91. 91

    cried Ivan Fyodorovich, with a malicious grin.

  92. 92

    Fyodor Pavlovich either failed to notice the malice or did not wish to, but caught at the grin:

  93. 93

    "Then you're going, you're going?

  94. 94

    I'll scribble you a note this minute."

  95. 95

    "I don't know whether I'll go, I don't know — I'll decide on the road."

  96. 96

    "Why on the road? Decide now.

  97. 97

    My dear boy, decide!

  98. 98

    Come to terms with him, write me a couple of lines, hand them to the priest, and he'll send your scrap of a note on to me in a flash.

  99. 99

    And after that I won't hold you back — off you go to Venice.

  100. 100

    The priest will get you back to the Volovya station with his own horses…"

  101. 101

    The old man was simply delighted; he scribbled the note, sent for the horses, and had a relish and some brandy brought out.

  102. 102

    When the old man was pleased, he always began to expand, but this time he seemed somehow to hold himself in check.

  103. 103

    About Dmitri Fyodorovich, for instance, he did not utter a single little word.

  104. 104

    Nor was he in the least moved by the parting.

  105. 105

    He even seemed at a loss for anything to talk about; and Ivan Fyodorovich noticed this clearly: "He's grown sick of me, though," he thought to himself.

  106. 106

    Only when he was already seeing his son off from the porch did the old man bustle a little, as it were, and start forward to kiss him.

  107. 107

    But Ivan Fyodorovich quickly held out his hand for a shake, plainly fending off the embrace.

  108. 108

    The old man understood at once and instantly reined himself in.

  109. 109

    "Well, God be with you, God be with you!"

  110. 110

    he repeated from the porch.

  111. 111

    "You'll come again sometime in your life, won't you?

  112. 112

    Well, do come — I'll always be glad.

  113. 113

    Well, Christ be with you!"

  114. 114

    Ivan Fyodorovich climbed into the tarantass.

  115. 115

    "Farewell, Ivan — don't be too hard on me!"

  116. 116

    the father called out for the last time.

  117. 117

    The whole household came out to see him off: Smerdyakov, Marfa, and Grigory.

  118. 118

    Ivan Fyodorovich gave each of them ten rubles.

  119. 119

    When he had already settled into the tarantass, Smerdyakov darted up to set the rug straight.

  120. 120

    "You see… I'm going to Chermashnya…"

  121. 121

    — it somehow burst out of Ivan Fyodorovich, again as it had the day before, slipping out of its own accord, and even with a kind of nervous little laugh.

  122. 122

    He remembered it for a long while afterward.

  123. 123

    "It seems people are right when they say it's worth speaking to a clever man," Smerdyakov answered firmly, fixing a penetrating look on Ivan Fyodorovich.

  124. 124

    The carriage started off and went racing away.

  125. 125

    The traveler's soul was in a fog, yet he gazed greedily about him — at the fields, the hills, the trees, at a flock of geese flying high above him across the clear sky.

  126. 126

    And all at once he felt so well.

  127. 127

    He tried to strike up a conversation with the driver, and something in what the peasant answered interested him terribly, but a minute later he realized that it had all flown past his ears and that, to tell the truth, he had not even understood what the peasant had said.

  128. 128

    He fell silent; it was fine even so — the air was clean, fresh, a little cold, the sky clear.

  129. 129

    The images of Alyosha and Katerina Ivanovna flickered through his mind; but he smiled quietly and quietly blew on the dear phantoms, and they flew off: "Their time will come yet," he thought.

  130. 130

    They covered the stage quickly, changed horses, and went tearing on toward Volovya.

  131. 131

    "Why is it worth speaking to a clever man — what did he mean by that?"

  132. 132

    — it suddenly took his breath away.

  133. 133

    "And why did I report to him that I was going to Chermashnya?" They galloped up to the Volovya station.

  134. 134

    Ivan Fyodorovich climbed out of the carriage, and the drivers crowded around him.

  135. 135

    They began to bargain about Chermashnya — twelve versts by a country road, with hired horses.

  136. 136

    He told them to harness up.

  137. 137

    He started into the station house, looked about him, glanced at the postmistress, and suddenly stepped back out onto the porch.

  138. 138

    "No need for Chermashnya."

  139. 139

    "I won't be late for the seven o'clock train at the railway, will I, lads?"

  140. 140

    "We'll make it just right."

  141. 141

    "Shall we harness up, then?"

  142. 142

    "Harness up at once."

  143. 143

    "Will any of you be in town tomorrow?"

  144. 144

    "How could there not be — there, Mitry will."

  145. 145

    "Couldn't you do me a service, Mitry?"

  146. 146

    "Call on my father, Fyodor Pavlovich Karamazov, and tell him that I did not go to Chermashnya."

  147. 147

    "Can you, or not?"

  148. 148

    "Why not call on him — we'll call; we've known Fyodor Pavlovich a very long time."

  149. 149

    "And here's something for your tea, because he probably won't give you any —"

  150. 150

    Ivan Fyodorovich laughed merrily.

  151. 151

    "And truly he won't," Mitry laughed too.

  152. 152

    "Thank you, sir, we'll be sure to carry it out —"

  153. 153

    At seven in the evening Ivan Fyodorovich got into the railway car and flew off toward Moscow.

  154. 154

    "Away with all that was before — done with the old world forever, and let there come from it neither word nor echo; into a new world, to new places, and without a backward glance!" But instead of rapture, such a darkness suddenly descended upon his soul, and such a grief began to ache in his heart, as he had never felt before in his whole life.

  155. 155

    He thought it over all night long; the train flew on, and only at daybreak, as he was already entering Moscow, did he suddenly seem to come to himself.

  156. 156

    "I am a scoundrel!"

  157. 157

    he whispered to himself.

  158. 158

    As for Fyodor Pavlovich, having seen his little son off, he was left very pleased.

  159. 159

    For two whole hours he felt almost happy and kept sipping his cognac; but suddenly a most vexing and most unpleasant circumstance occurred in the house, one that in an instant threw Fyodor Pavlovich into great consternation: Smerdyakov had gone down into the cellar for something and fallen from the top step.

  160. 160

    It was a good thing, at least, that Marfa Ignatyevna happened to be in the yard just then and heard him in time.

  161. 161

    She did not see the fall, but she heard the cry — a peculiar, strange cry, though one long familiar to her — the cry of an epileptic dropping in a fit.

  162. 162

    Whether the fit had come over him at the moment he was going down the steps, so that he must of course have tumbled down at once, senseless — or whether, on the contrary, the fit of Smerdyakov, a known epileptic, had been brought on by the fall and the shock — there was no way to make out; but they found him already at the bottom of the cellar, writhing and convulsing, thrashing about, with foam at his mouth.

  163. 163

    At first they thought he had surely broken something, an arm or a leg, and injured himself badly, but "the Lord preserved him," as Marfa Ignatyevna put it: nothing of the sort had happened, only it was hard to get hold of him and carry him up out of the cellar into the light of God's day.

  164. 164

    But they asked the neighbors for help and somehow managed it.

  165. 165

    Fyodor Pavlovich himself was present at this whole ceremony, himself helping out, visibly frightened and as if at a loss.

  166. 166

    The sick man, however, did not come to: the fits, though they let up for a time, kept returning, and everyone concluded that the same thing would happen as the year before, when he had likewise fallen by accident from the attic.

  167. 167

    They recalled that back then they had applied ice to the crown of his head.

  168. 168

    There was still some ice to be found in the cellar, and Marfa Ignatyevna saw to it, while toward evening Fyodor Pavlovich sent for Doctor Herzenstube, who arrived without delay.

  169. 169

    Having examined the patient carefully (he was the most careful and attentive doctor in the whole province, an elderly and most worthy little old man), he concluded that the fit was extraordinary and "might pose a danger," that for the present he, Herzenstube, did not yet understand the whole of it, but that tomorrow morning, if the current remedies did not help, he would resolve to apply others.

  170. 170

    They laid the sick man down in the outbuilding, in a little room next to the quarters of Grigory and Marfa Ignatyevna.

  171. 171

    After that Fyodor Pavlovich endured all day nothing but one misfortune after another: Marfa Ignatyevna cooked the dinner, and the soup, by comparison with Smerdyakov's making, came out "like dishwater," while the chicken turned out so dried up that there was no possibility of chewing it.

  172. 172

    To her master's bitter, though just, reproaches Marfa Ignatyevna retorted that the chicken had been very old to begin with, and that she herself had never trained as a cook.

  173. 173

    Toward evening another worry arose: Fyodor Pavlovich was informed that Grigory, who had fallen ill two days before, had now taken almost entirely to his bed — his lower back had given out.

  174. 174

    Fyodor Pavlovich finished his tea as early as he could and shut himself up alone in the house.

  175. 175

    He was in a terrible and anxious state of expectation.

  176. 176

    The fact was that on that very evening he was expecting Grushenka's arrival as almost a certainty; at the very least he had received from Smerdyakov, early in the morning, all but an assurance that "they had undoubtedly promised to come, sir."

  177. 177

    The restless little old man's heart beat anxiously; he wandered through his empty rooms and listened.

  178. 178

    He had to keep his ears open: Dmitry Fyodorovich might be lying in wait for her somewhere, and the moment she knocked at the window (Smerdyakov had assured Fyodor Pavlovich two days before that he had told her where and how to knock), the door had to be opened as quickly as possible, and she must on no account be kept waiting even a needless second in the entryway, lest — God forbid — she take fright and run off.

  179. 179

    It was a fretful business for Fyodor Pavlovich, but never yet had his heart bathed in a sweeter hope: this time one could say almost for certain that she would surely come!..

The particulars

The text
Братья Карамазовы, Fyodor Dostoevsky. Book V — Pro and Contra.
Translation
Public-domain Russian (Dostoevsky, d. 1881). Translation © 2026 1732 Studios.
Words
Every word of the text, by letter.
Data
JSON · Markdown · A guide for agents
Two whoopie pies and a pine. An inside joke.