The Brothers Karamazov 1732 Studios

Russian · Book VII — Alyosha

I. Тлетворный дух

The Breath of Corruption

165 sentences · 411 notes

Tap a sentence to open its words.

  1. 1

    The body of the departed hieroschemamonk, Father Zossima, was made ready for burial according to the established rite.

    Телоthe bodyтело · noun, nominative, neuter, singulardirect object of приготовили
    усопшегоdepartedусопший · adjective, genitive, masculine, singularmodifies иеросхимонаха
    иеросхимонахаhieroschemamonkиеросхимонах · noun, genitive, masculine, singularmodifies Тело

    иеросхимонах is a monk of the highest monastic rank (great schema) who is also an ordained priest.

    отцаFatherотец · noun, genitive, masculine, singularmodifies иеросхимонаха
    ЗосимыZosimaЗосима · proper noun, genitive, masculine, singularin apposition to отца
    приготовилиwas made readyприготовить · verb, past, indicative, active, plural, perfectivemain verb of the sentence
    кforк · prepositionpreposition marking погребению
    погребениюburialпогребение · noun, dative, neuter, singularoblique complement of приготовили
    поaccording toпо · prepositionpreposition marking чину
    установленномуestablishedустановить · verb, past, passive, participle, masculine, singular, dative, perfectivemodifies чину
    чинуriteчин · noun, dative, masculine, singularoblique complement of приготовили
  2. 2

    As is known, the bodies of dead monks and schemamonks are not washed.

  3. 3

    "When one of the monks departeth unto the Lord (so it is said in the Great Book of Needs), then the appointed monk (that is, the one designated for this) wipes his body with warm water, first tracing with a sponge (that is, a Greek sponge) a cross upon the brow of the deceased, upon his breast, upon his hands and feet and knees, and nothing more."

  4. 4

    All this Father Paissy himself performed over the departed.

  5. 5

    After the wiping he clothed him in the monastic garb and wrapped him in the mantle; for which, according to the rule, he slit it in several places, so as to wrap it crosswise.

  6. 6

    On his head he set the cowl with the eight-pointed cross.

  7. 7

    The cowl was left open, but the face of the departed was covered with the black veil.

  8. 8

    Into his hands they laid an icon of the Saviour.

  9. 9

    In this state, toward morning, they transferred him into the coffin (long since made ready beforehand).

  10. 10

    The coffin they resolved to leave in the cell (in the first, large room, the very one in which the late elder had received both the brethren and the laity) for the whole day.

  11. 11

    Since by his rank the departed was a hieroschemamonk, it was fitting that hieromonks and hierodeacons should read over him not the Psalter but the Gospel.

  12. 12

    The reading was begun, immediately after the requiem, by Father Iosif; while Father Paissy, who himself wished to read afterward through the whole day and the whole night, was for the time being still very busy and preoccupied together with the Father Superior of the hermitage, for there had suddenly begun to make itself felt — and the further it went, the more so — both among the monastery brethren and among the laity who were arriving in crowds from the monastery guest-houses and from the town, something extraordinary, a kind of unheard-of and "unseemly" agitation and impatient expectation.

  13. 13

    Both the Superior and Father Paissy made every effort to calm, so far as they could, those who were so fussily worked up.

  14. 14

    When the day had already grown light enough, some from the town even began to arrive who had brought their sick along with them, especially children — as if they had been waiting on purpose precisely for this moment, evidently trusting in an immediate power of healing that, by their faith, could not be slow to reveal itself.

  15. 15

    And it was only then that it came to light to what degree everyone among us had grown accustomed, even during his lifetime, to regard the departed elder as an unquestionable and great saint.

  16. 16

    And among those arriving were by no means people of the common folk alone.

  17. 17

    This great expectation of the faithful, displayed so hastily and so nakedly, even with impatience and almost with insistence, struck Father Paissy as an unquestionable temptation, one that, though he had long foreseen it, in actual fact exceeded his expectations.

  18. 18

    Meeting some of the agitated monks, Father Paissy even began to admonish them: "Such an expectation, and so immediate, of something great," he said, "is a frivolity possible only among worldly people, but unseemly in us."

  19. 19

    But they paid him little heed, and Father Paissy noted this with uneasiness, notwithstanding that even he himself (if everything is to be recalled truthfully), though he was indignant at expectations so excessively impatient and found in them a frivolity and vanity, yet secretly, within himself, in the depths of his own soul, awaited very nearly the same thing as these agitated ones did — something he could not but confess to himself.

  20. 20

    Nonetheless, certain encounters were especially unpleasant to him, rousing in him, by some presentiment, grave misgivings.

  21. 21

    In the crowd pressing within the departed one's cell he noticed, with an inward revulsion (for which he at once reproached himself), the presence, for instance, of Rakitin, or of a distant guest — the monk from Obdorsk, who was still lingering in the monastery — and both of these Father Paissy for some reason suddenly took to be suspect, though they were not the only ones who might be marked in that same sense.

  22. 22

    Of all the agitated, the monk from Obdorsk stood out as the most restless; he could be spotted everywhere, in every spot: everywhere he was questioning, everywhere listening in, everywhere whispering with some peculiar, mysterious air.

  23. 23

    The expression of his face, moreover, was of the utmost impatience, and as though already irritated that what was awaited so long was not coming to pass.

  24. 24

    As for Rakitin, he, as it turned out afterward, had found himself in the hermitage so early upon a special errand from Madame Khokhlakova.

  25. 25

    This kind but spineless woman, who could not herself be admitted into the hermitage, had no sooner woken and learned of the elder's passing than she was suddenly seized by so impetuous a curiosity that she at once dispatched Rakitin to the hermitage in her place, charging him to observe everything and to report to her in writing without delay, roughly every half-hour, about "everything that might happen."

  26. 26

    Rakitin she took to be a most pious and believing young man — so well did he know how to get on with everyone and present himself to each according to that person's wishes, provided only that he discerned in it the slightest advantage for himself.

  27. 27

    The day was clear and bright, and of the pilgrims who had arrived many crowded about the hermitage graves, which were clustered most densely around the church, though also scattered throughout the whole hermitage.

  28. 28

    As he went about the hermitage, Father Paissy suddenly remembered Alyosha, and that he had not seen him for a long while — since nearly the night itself.

  29. 29

    And no sooner had he thought of him than he caught sight of him at once, in the most remote corner of the hermitage, by the wall, sitting on the gravestone of a certain monk who had reposed in days of old and was renowned for his ascetic feats.

  30. 30

    He sat with his back to the hermitage, his face toward the wall, and as if hiding behind the monument.

  31. 31

    Coming right up to him, Father Paissy saw that he, covering his face with both palms, was weeping — soundlessly, yet bitterly — his whole body shaking with sobs.

  32. 32

    Father Paissy stood over him for a little while.

  33. 33

    "Enough, dear son, enough, friend," he uttered at last, with feeling, "what ails you? Rejoice, do not weep. Or do you not know that this day is the greatest of his days? Where is he now, at this very minute — only call that to mind!"

  34. 34

    Alyosha glanced up at him, uncovering his face, swollen with tears like a small child's, but at once, without a word, turned away and again hid behind both palms.

  35. 35

    "Well, perhaps that is as it should be," said Father Paissy thoughtfully, "perhaps; then weep — Christ has sent you these tears."

  36. 36

    "These tender little tears of yours will serve only as a rest for your soul and to gladden your dear heart," he added, now to himself, as he moved off from Alyosha, thinking of him with love.

  37. 37

    He moved off, however, as quickly as he could, for he felt that he himself, perhaps, looking at the boy, would burst into tears.

  38. 38

    Meanwhile time was passing; the monastery services and the requiems for the departed continued in due order.

  39. 39

    Father Paissy again relieved Father Iosif at the coffin and again took over from him the reading of the Gospel.

  40. 40

    But not yet three o'clock in the afternoon had passed when there came to pass something of which I made mention back at the close of the previous book — something so wholly unexpected by us, and so against the common hope, that, I repeat, the detailed and trivial tale of this incident is even to this day recalled with extraordinary vividness in our town and throughout all our district.

  41. 41

    Here I will add once more, on my own personal account: it is almost repugnant to me to recall this fussy and scandalous occurrence, in essence the emptiest and most natural of things, and I should certainly have left it out of my narrative altogether, without any mention, had it not exerted a most powerful and definite influence upon the soul and heart of the chief — though only future — hero of my story, Alyosha, working in his soul as it were a fracture and an upheaval, one that shook but also strengthened his mind, now finally, for the whole of his life and toward a definite goal.

  42. 42

    And so, to the story.

  43. 43

    When, while it was still before daybreak, they had laid the elder's body, prepared for burial, into the coffin and carried it out into the first room, the former reception room, a question arose among those standing by the coffin: ought the windows in the room to be opened?

  44. 44

    But this question, voiced by someone in passing and offhandedly, was left without an answer and went almost unnoticed — except that some of those present did mark it, and even then only to themselves, in the sense that to expect putrefaction and a breath of corruption from the body of such a departed one was sheer absurdity, deserving even of pity (if not of a sneer) toward the small faith and frivolity of the one who had uttered the question.

  45. 45

    For they expected the very opposite.

  46. 46

    And then, shortly after noon, something began that was at first taken in by those coming and going only in silence and to themselves, and even with a visible dread on each one's part of confiding to anyone the thought that was dawning on him; but by three o'clock in the afternoon it had revealed itself already so plainly and incontestably that word of it flew in an instant through the whole hermitage and among all the pilgrims — the hermitage's visitors — at once penetrated the monastery as well and threw all the monastery folk into amazement, and at last, after the very shortest span, reached the town too and stirred up everyone in it, believers and unbelievers alike.

  47. 47

    The unbelievers rejoiced, and as for the believers, there proved to be some among them who rejoiced even more than the unbelievers themselves, for "men love the fall of the righteous and his disgrace," as the late elder himself had said in one of his homilies.

  48. 48

    The thing was that there began to issue from the coffin, little by little, but ever more perceptibly the further it went, a breath of corruption, which by three o'clock in the afternoon was already too plainly manifest and was steadily growing stronger.

  49. 49

    And for a long time there had not been — indeed it was impossible even to recall, out of the whole past life of our monastery — such a scandal, so crudely unbridled and in any other case so utterly impossible, as the one that broke out immediately following this event among the very monks themselves.

  50. 50

    Afterward, even after many years, certain sensible monks of ours, recalling that whole day in detail, would marvel and be horrified at the manner in which the scandal could then have reached such a pitch.

  51. 51

    For even before this it had happened that monks of a most righteous life would die — monks whose righteousness was plain for all to see, God-fearing elders — and yet from their humble coffins too there had issued a breath of corruption, appearing naturally, as it does with all the dead; but this had produced neither scandal nor even the slightest agitation of any kind.

  52. 52

    Of course, there had been certain ones among us, too, from those who reposed in days of old, the memory of whom was still living in the monastery, and whose remains, according to tradition, had shown no decay — which had moved the brethren tenderly and mysteriously, and was preserved in their memory as something beautiful and miraculous, and as a promise of yet greater glory in the future from their tombs, if only, by God's will, the time for that should come.

  53. 53

    Among such, the memory was especially preserved of the elder Iov, who had lived to a hundred and five, a renowned ascetic, a great faster and keeper of silence, who had reposed long ago, back in the eighteen-tens, and whose grave was shown to all newly arriving pilgrims with a particular and extraordinary reverence, with mysterious allusions, on that occasion, to certain great hopes.

  54. 54

    (This is the very grave on which Father Paissy had found Alyosha sitting that morning.)

  55. 55

    Besides this elder who had reposed in days of old, just such a memory was alive also of one who had passed away comparatively not long ago, the great Father hieroschemamonk, the elder Varsonofy — the very one from whom Father Zossima had received the eldership, and whom, during his lifetime, all the pilgrims who came to the monastery regarded outright as a holy fool.

  56. 56

    Of both these it was preserved in tradition that they had lain in their coffins as though living, and had been buried wholly incorrupt, and that even their faces had as it were grown luminous in the coffin.

  57. 57

    And some even insisted in their recollections that from their bodies a fragrance had been distinctly perceptible.

  58. 58

    But despite even such impressive recollections as these, it would still be difficult to explain the direct cause for which, at the coffin of the elder Zossima, so frivolous, absurd, and malicious a phenomenon could have come about.

  59. 59

    As for me personally, I suppose that many different things converged here at once, many varied causes acting together.

  60. 60

    Among such, for instance, was even that very deep-rooted enmity toward the eldership, as toward a pernicious innovation, that lay hidden in the monastery in the minds of many monks still.

  61. 61

    And then, of course, and chief of all, there was envy of the departed one's holiness, which had been established so firmly during his lifetime that to gainsay it had seemed almost forbidden.

  62. 62

    For although the late elder had drawn many to himself — and not so much by miracles as by love — and had raised up around himself as it were a whole world of those who loved him, nonetheless, and even all the more for that very reason, by that same thing he had bred for himself enviers as well, and in their train bitter enemies too, both open and secret, and not only among the monastery folk but even among the laity.

  63. 63

    He had done no harm to anyone, for instance, and yet there was this: "Why is it that they hold him to be so holy?"

  64. 64

    And this one question alone, repeating itself little by little, at last bred a whole abyss of the most insatiable malice.

  65. 65

    That is why I think, too, that many, on catching the breath of corruption from his body — and so quickly at that, for not even a day had passed since his death — were immeasurably gladdened; just as, among those devoted to the elder and who had revered him until now, there were found at once such as were almost offended and personally aggrieved by this event.

  66. 66

    The gradual course of the affair came about in the following manner.

  67. 67

    As soon as the decay began to make itself felt, one could tell, merely from the look of the monks who entered the departed one's cell, why they were coming.

  68. 68

    One would come in, stand for a short while, and go out to confirm the news the sooner to the others, who were waiting in a crowd outside.

  69. 69

    Some of those waiting shook their heads in sorrow, but others would not even hide their joy now, which shone openly in their malevolent gazes.

  70. 70

    And no one reproached them any longer, no one raised a kindly voice — which was indeed strange, for those devoted to the departed elder were after all the majority in the monastery; but the Lord himself, evidently, had allowed that on this occasion the minority should for a time gain the upper hand.

  71. 71

    Soon laymen too, the more educated of the visitors, began to appear in the cell as the same sort of spies.

  72. 72

    Of the common folk, however, few came in, though many of them had crowded at the hermitage gates.

  73. 73

    It is beyond doubt that it was precisely after three o'clock that the influx of lay visitors increased greatly, and precisely in consequence of the scandalous news.

  74. 74

    Those who might, perhaps, not have come that day at all and had not meant to come, now drove out on purpose, among them some persons of considerable rank.

  75. 75

    Outward decorum, however, was as yet still unbroken, and Father Paissy went on reading the Gospel aloud, firmly and distinctly, with a stern face, as though not noticing what was taking place, though he had long since noticed that something extraordinary was afoot.

  76. 76

    But now voices began to reach even him — at first quite low, but gradually hardening and growing bolder.

  77. 77

    "So God's judgment, it seems, is not the same as man's!" Father Paissy suddenly heard.

  78. 78

    The first of all to utter this was one layman, a town official, a man already elderly and, so far as was known of him, very devout; but, having spoken it aloud, he was only repeating what the monks had long been repeating among themselves, into one another's ears.

  79. 79

    They had long since uttered this hopeless word, and the worst of it was that with almost every passing minute a certain triumph revealed itself and grew at this word.

  80. 80

    Soon, however, even decorum itself began to be broken, and it was just as if everyone felt himself somehow even entitled to break it.

  81. 81

    "And why should this have happened," some of the monks said, at first as if even with regret, "his body was not large, dried up, shrunk to the bones — where could the smell come from here?"

  82. 82

    "It means that God meant on purpose to give a sign," others hastily added, and their opinion was accepted without dispute and at once; for they pointed out, again, that even were the smell natural, as from every departed sinner, it would still have come later, not with such overly plain haste — at the least after a day's time — whereas "this one has forestalled nature," so it must be that here was none but God and his special finger.

  83. 83

    He had meant to give a sign.

  84. 84

    This judgment struck home irresistibly.

  85. 85

    The gentle Father hieromonk Iosif, the librarian, the late elder's favorite, tried to object to some of the slanderers, that "it is not so everywhere, after all," and that this necessity of the incorruption of the righteous one's body was no dogma of Orthodoxy but merely an opinion, and that even in the most Orthodox lands, on Mount Athos for instance, they are not so troubled by a breath of corruption, and that there it is not bodily incorruption that is held to be the chief sign of the glorification of the saved, but the color of their bones, after their bodies have lain already many years in the earth and even decayed in it — "and if the bones be found yellow as wax, then there is the chief sign that the Lord has glorified the departed righteous one; but if they be found not yellow but black, it means the Lord has not deemed such a one worthy of glory — that is how it is on Athos, that great place where from of old Orthodoxy is preserved inviolate and in the brightest purity," Father Iosif concluded.

  86. 86

    But the humble Father's words carried no weight and even provoked a mocking rebuff: "That is all learning and innovations, no need even to listen," the monks decided to themselves.

  87. 87

    "With us it is in the old way; few enough are the innovations cropping up nowadays — are we to ape them all?" others added.

  88. 88

    "We have had no fewer holy fathers than they have. There they sit under the Turk and have forgotten everything. Their Orthodoxy went muddy long ago, and they have no bells either," the most mocking of them put in.

  89. 89

    Father Iosif withdrew in grief, all the more since he had not voiced his own opinion very firmly, but as though he himself had little faith in it.

  90. 90

    But with dismay he foresaw that something very unseemly was beginning, and that even outright insubordination was raising its head.

  91. 91

    Little by little, in Father Iosif's wake, all the reasonable voices fell silent too.

  92. 92

    And it somehow so came about that all those who had loved the late elder, and who with tender obedience had embraced the institution of the eldership, suddenly took a terrible fright at something, and, meeting one another, would only peer timidly into each other's faces.

  93. 93

    The enemies of the eldership, as of an innovation, proudly lifted their heads.

  94. 94

    "From the late elder Varsonofy there came not only no smell, but a fragrance was distilled," they recalled gloatingly, "but he earned it not by the eldership, but by the fact that he was himself a righteous man."

  95. 95

    And in the wake of this, upon the newly departed elder there now rained down condemnations and even outright accusations: "He taught wrongly; he taught that life is a great joy and not a tearful humility," said some, of the most muddle-headed.

  96. 96

    "He believed in the fashionable way; he did not acknowledge a material fire in hell," others added, more muddle-headed still.

  97. 97

    "He was not strict in his fasting, he allowed himself sweets, ate cherry preserve with his tea, was very fond of it, the ladies sent it to him. Is it for a schemamonk to be drinking tea?" came from some of the envious.

  98. 98

    "He sat there grown proud," the most gloating recalled with cruelty, "he reckoned himself a saint, people fell on their knees before him, and he took it as his due."

  99. 99

    "He abused the sacrament of confession," the most rabid opponents of the eldership added in a malicious whisper — and this even from among the very oldest and most austere monks in their devotions, true keepers of fasts and silence, who had held their tongues during the departed one's lifetime but now suddenly unsealed their lips, which was already dreadful, for their words had a powerful influence on the young and not yet settled monks.

  100. 100

    All this the Obdorsk guest, too, the little monk from Saint Sylvester's, listened to attentively, sighing deeply and nodding his head: "No, it seems Father Ferapont judged rightly yesterday," he kept thinking to himself — and just then, as it happened, Father Ferapont appeared, as if precisely to deepen the shock, he had come out.

  101. 101

    I have mentioned before that he rarely came out of his little wooden cell by the apiary, that even at church he would for long stretches fail to appear, and that this was indulged in him as in a supposed holy fool, no one binding him by the rule common to all.

  102. 102

    But to tell the whole truth, all this was indulged in him even out of a certain necessity.

  103. 103

    For to burden insistently with the common rule so great a faster and keeper of silence, one who prayed day and night (he even fell asleep on his knees), seemed somehow even shameful, if he himself did not wish to submit.

  104. 104

    "He is holier than all of us, and fulfills more than the rule demands," the monks would have said then, "and as for his not going to church, that means he himself knows when he is to go; he has a rule of his own."

  105. 105

    It was for the sake of this probable murmuring and scandal that they left Father Ferapont in peace.

  106. 106

    The elder Zossima, Father Ferapont disliked exceedingly, as was already known to everyone; and now to him, in his little cell, there suddenly came the news that "God's judgment, then, is not the same as men's, and that this one has even forestalled nature."

  107. 107

    One must suppose that among the first to run and convey the news to him was the Obdorsk guest, who had visited him the day before and gone away from him in horror.

  108. 108

    I have mentioned, too, that Father Paissy, standing firm and unshakable as he read over the coffin, though he could not hear or see what was going on outside the cell, yet in his heart unerringly divined all the main of it, for he knew his world through and through.

  109. 109

    Nor was he dismayed, but awaited everything that might still come to pass, without fear, following with a piercing gaze the coming outcome of the agitation, which already presented itself to his mind's eye.

  110. 110

    When suddenly an extraordinary noise in the entryway, already plainly breaking the decorum, struck his ear.

  111. 111

    The door was flung wide open, and on the threshold appeared Father Ferapont.

  112. 112

    Behind him, as could be observed — and it was even plainly visible from the cell — many monks who had accompanied him had crowded below by the little porch, and among them laymen too.

  113. 113

    Those accompanying him, however, did not come in and did not mount the porch, but, halting, waited to see what Father Ferapont would say and do next, for they had a presentiment, and even with a certain dread, despite all their boldness, that he had come for no idle purpose.

  114. 114

    Halting on the threshold, Father Ferapont raised his arms, and from beneath his right arm peered the sharp, inquisitive little eyes of the Obdorsk guest, the only one who could not contain himself and had run up the little stairway after Father Ferapont, out of his vast curiosity.

  115. 115

    The rest, save for him, the moment the door was flung noisily wide, on the contrary pressed themselves still further back from a sudden fear.

  116. 116

    Lifting his arms aloft, Father Ferapont suddenly cried out:

  117. 117

    "Casting out, I cast out!" — and at once he began, turning in turn toward all four directions, to make the sign of the cross over the walls and all four corners of the cell with his hand.

  118. 118

    This action of Father Ferapont's was at once understood by those who accompanied him; for they knew that he always did so, wherever he went, and that he would neither sit down nor speak a word before he had driven out the unclean spirit.

  119. 119

    "Satan, get thee gone, Satan, get thee gone!" he kept repeating with each sign of the cross. "Casting out, I cast out!" he cried out again.

  120. 120

    He was in his coarse cassock, girded with a rope.

  121. 121

    From beneath the coarse hempen shirt his bare chest showed, overgrown with grey hair.

  122. 122

    His feet were altogether bare.

  123. 123

    The moment he began to wave his arms, the cruel chains he wore beneath his cassock started to shake and clank.

  124. 124

    Father Paisy broke off his reading, stepped forward, and stood before him, waiting.

  125. 125

    "Wherefore hast thou come, honored father? Wherefore dost thou break our good order? Wherefore dost thou trouble the humble flock?" he said at last, looking at him sternly.

  126. 126

    "For what cause art thou come? What dost thou seek? How dost thou believe?" cried Father Ferapont, playing the holy fool. "I have hastened hither to drive out these guests of yours, the foul devils. I look to see how many of them you have gathered up without me. With a birch besom I would sweep them out."

  127. 127

    "Thou drivest out the unclean one, yet perhaps thou thyself art serving him," Father Paisy went on without fear, "and who can say of himself, 'I am holy'? Canst thou, father?"

  128. 128

    "Foul am I, not holy. I will not sit in the elder's chair, nor will I have men bow down to me as to an idol!" thundered Father Ferapont. "In these days the people are destroying the holy faith. The dead man, this saint of yours," he turned to the crowd, pointing his finger at the coffin, "denied the devils. He gave out a purge against the devils. And so they have bred among you, like spiders in the corners. And now today he himself has stunk. In this we behold a great sign from the Lord."

  129. 129

    And indeed it once happened just so, in the lifetime of Father Zosima.

  130. 130

    An unclean power began to appear to one of the monks, first in dreams and at last in his waking hours as well.

  131. 131

    When at last, in the greatest terror, he disclosed this to the elder, the elder counseled him to unceasing prayer and a stricter fast.

  132. 132

    But when even this did not help, he advised him, without giving up the fast and the prayer, to take a certain medicine.

  133. 133

    Many were scandalized at this then, and spoke of it among themselves, shaking their heads — and none more than Father Ferapont, to whom certain slanderers at once hastened to report this "extraordinary" disposition of the elder's in so singular a case.

  134. 134

    "Depart, father!" Father Paisy pronounced commandingly. "It is not men who judge, but God. Perhaps it is some 'sign' that we behold here, such a one as neither thou, nor I, nor any man has power to understand. Depart, father, and trouble not the flock!" he repeated insistently.

  135. 135

    "He kept not the fasts according to the rule of his schema, and therefore the sign has come forth. This is plain, and to hide it is a sin!" the zealot would not be calmed, carried away in a fervor that was not according to reason. "By sweetmeats was he seduced; the ladies brought them to him in their pockets; on tea he made himself dainty, he served his belly, filling it with delicacies, while his mind he filled with arrogant thoughts… And for this he has suffered shame…"

  136. 136

    "Frivolous are thy words, father!" Father Paisy too raised his voice. "At thy fasting and thy ascetic labor I marvel, but frivolous are thy words, as though some youth in the world had uttered them, fickle and childish of mind. Depart, then, father, I command thee," Father Paisy thundered in conclusion.

  137. 137

    "I shall depart!" said Father Ferapont, somewhat abashed, as it were, yet not abandoning his rancor. "You learned ones! In your great wisdom you have set yourselves up above my nothingness. I came hither barely lettered, and here I have forgotten even what I knew; the Lord God Himself has protected me, the little one, from your great learning…"

  138. 138

    Father Paisy stood over him and waited firmly.

  139. 139

    Father Ferapont fell silent, and suddenly, growing mournful and pressing his right palm to his cheek, pronounced in a chanting voice, gazing at the coffin of the departed elder:

  140. 140

    "Over him tomorrow they will sing 'The Helper and Defender' — a most glorious canon — but over me, when I croak, only 'What earthly sweetness' — a paltry little hymn," he said tearfully and pityingly.

  141. 141

    "You have grown proud and exalted yourselves; this place is empty!" he suddenly screamed like a madman and, with a sweep of his hand, turned swiftly and went swiftly down the steps from the little porch.

  142. 142

    The crowd that had been waiting below wavered; some followed him at once, but others lingered, for the cell was still open, and Father Paisy, having come out onto the porch after Father Ferapont, stood and watched.

  143. 143

    But the old man, in his frenzy, had not yet finished it all: having gone some twenty paces, he suddenly turned toward the setting sun, raised both arms above himself, and — as though someone had cut him down — collapsed to the ground with a tremendous cry:

  144. 144

    "My Lord has conquered! Christ has conquered, as the sun goes down!" he cried frenziedly, lifting his arms toward the sun, and, falling face down to the earth, he sobbed aloud like a little child, his whole body shaking with his tears, his arms spread out across the ground.

  145. 145

    Now everyone rushed to him; exclamations broke out, answering sobs… A kind of frenzy seized them all.

  146. 146

    "There is one who is holy! There is one who is righteous!" cried voices, no longer fearful. "It is he who ought to sit among the elders," others added, now spitefully.

  147. 147

    "He will not sit among the elders… He himself will refuse it… he will not serve the accursed innovation… he will not ape their foolishness," other voices took up at once, and it is hard to imagine how far this might have gone, had not the bell struck at that very minute, summoning them to the service.

  148. 148

    Everyone suddenly began to cross themselves.

  149. 149

    Father Ferapont too rose and, guarding himself with the sign of the cross, went off toward his cell without looking back, still going on with his exclamations, but now something altogether incoherent.

  150. 150

    A few, in small number, made to trail after him, but the greater part began to disperse, hurrying to the service.

  151. 151

    Father Paisy handed the reading over to Father Iosif and went down.

  152. 152

    The frenzied cries of the zealots could not shake him, yet his heart suddenly grew heavy and ached over something in particular, and he felt it.

  153. 153

    He stopped and suddenly asked himself: "Why does this sadness of mine reach even to a faltering of the spirit?" — and to his astonishment he grasped at once that this sudden sadness of his arose, apparently, from a cause most small and particular: the matter was that, in the crowd which had been pressing just now at the entrance to the cell, he had noticed, among the others who were agitated, Alyosha as well, and he remembered that, on catching sight of him, he had felt at that moment in his heart something like a pain.

  154. 154

    "Can it be that this young one means so much now to my heart?" he suddenly asked himself in astonishment.

  155. 155

    At that very minute Alyosha happened to be passing by him, as though hurrying somewhere, but not in the direction of the church.

  156. 156

    Their eyes met.

  157. 157

    Alyosha quickly looked away and dropped his eyes to the ground, and from the young man's very look alone Father Paisy guessed what a powerful change was taking place in him at that moment.

  158. 158

    "Have you too been scandalized?" Father Paisy suddenly exclaimed. "Can it be that you too are with the men of little faith!" he added grievously.

  159. 159

    Alyosha stopped and gazed somehow uncertainly at Father Paisy, but again quickly looked away and again dropped his eyes to the ground.

  160. 160

    He stood sideways and did not turn his face toward the one who had questioned him.

  161. 161

    Father Paisy watched him attentively.

  162. 162

    "Where are you hurrying to? They are ringing the bell for the service," he asked again, but Alyosha once more gave no answer.

  163. 163

    "Or are you leaving the hermitage? And how, without asking leave, without a blessing?"

  164. 164

    Alyosha suddenly gave a crooked smile, and strangely, very strangely, raised his eyes to the father who was questioning him — to the very man to whom his dying guide had entrusted him, the one who had been the master of his heart and mind, his beloved elder — and suddenly, still without a word as before, he waved his hand, as though caring nothing even for respect, and with rapid steps went off toward the gates leading out of the hermitage.

  165. 165

    "You will come back yet!" Father Paisy whispered, watching after him with grievous astonishment.

The particulars

The text
Братья Карамазовы, Fyodor Dostoevsky. Book VII — Alyosha.
Translation
Public-domain Russian (Dostoevsky, d. 1881). Translation © 2026 1732 Studios.
Words
Every word of the text, by letter.
Data
JSON · Markdown · A guide for agents
Two whoopie pies and a pine. An inside joke.