The Brothers Karamazov 1732 Studios

Russian · Book IX — The Preliminary Investigation

III. Хождение души по мытарствам. Мытарство первое

The Sufferings of a Soul — The First Ordeal

219 sentences · 435 notes

Tap a sentence to open its words.

  1. 1

    And so Mitya sat there, surveying those present with a wild look, not understanding what was being said to him.

    Итакand soитак · adverbintroduces the sentence
    МитяMityaМитя · proper noun, nominative, masculine, singularsubject of сидел
    сиделsatсидеть · verb, past, indicative, active, singular, imperfectivemain verb of the sentence
    иandи · conjunctionlinks the coordination
    дикимwildдикий · adjective, instrumental, masculine, singularmodifies взглядом
    взглядомlookвзгляд · noun, instrumental, masculine, singularoblique complement of озирал
    озиралsurveyedозирать · verb, past, indicative, active, singular, imperfectivecoordinated with сидел
    присутствующихthose presentприсутствующий · noun (substantivized participle), accusative, pluraldirect object of озирал
    неnotне · particlemodifies понимая
    понимаяunderstandingпонимать · verb, present, active, converb, imperfectiveadverbial clause on озирал
    чтоwhatчто · subordinating conjunction/pronounintroduces the clause of говорят
    емуto himон · pronoun, dative, masculine, singularindirect object of говорят
    говорятwas being saidговорить · verb, present, indicative, active, third, plural, imperfectiveclausal complement of понимая
  2. 2

    Suddenly he rose, flung his arms up, and shouted aloud:

  3. 3

    "Not guilty!"

  4. 4

    "Of this blood I am not guilty!"

  5. 5

    "Of my father's blood I am not guilty…"

  6. 6

    "I wanted to kill him, but I am not guilty!"

  7. 7

    "It was not I!"

  8. 8

    But no sooner had he managed to shout this than Grushenka darted out from behind the curtains and threw herself down at the very feet of the police captain.

  9. 9

    "It was I, I, accursed creature that I am, I am the guilty one!"

  10. 10

    she cried out in a wail that tore at the soul, all in tears, stretching out her arms to them all, "it was because of me that he killed!.."

  11. 11

    "It was I who tormented him and drove him to it!"

  12. 12

    "And that poor little old man, now dead, I tormented him too, out of my own spite, and drove him to it as well!"

  13. 13

    "I am the guilty one, I first of all, I above all, I am to blame!"

  14. 14

    "Yes, you are the guilty one!"

  15. 15

    "You are the chief criminal!"

  16. 16

    "You are a wild thing, you are a wanton, you are the one most to blame," bawled the police captain, shaking his fist at her — but here he was quickly and firmly silenced.

  17. 17

    The prosecutor even threw his arms around him.

  18. 18

    "This is becoming quite a disorder, Mikhail Makarovich," he exclaimed, "you are positively obstructing the inquiry… you are spoiling the case…"

  19. 19

    he gasped, almost choking.

  20. 20

    "Measures must be taken, measures must be taken, measures must be taken!"

  21. 21

    Nikolai Parfenovich too boiled over dreadfully, "otherwise it is positively impossible!.."

  22. 22

    "Try us together!"

  23. 23

    Grushenka went on exclaiming in a frenzy, still on her knees.

  24. 24

    "Punish us together — I will go with him now even to the scaffold!"

  25. 25

    "Grusha, my life, my blood, my holy one!"

  26. 26

    Mitya too threw himself down on his knees beside her and clasped her tightly in his arms.

  27. 27

    "Don't believe her," he cried, "she is not guilty of anything, not of any blood and not of anything at all!"

  28. 28

    He remembered afterward that several men had dragged him away from her by force, and that she had suddenly been led off, and that he came to his senses only when he was already sitting at the table.

  29. 29

    Beside him and behind him stood men wearing official badges.

  30. 30

    Across the table from him, on the sofa, sat Nikolai Parfenovich, the examining magistrate, who kept urging him to take a little water from the glass standing on the table: "It will refresh you, it will calm you, don't be afraid, don't be uneasy," he added with extreme courtesy.

  31. 31

    And suddenly — he remembered this — Mitya became dreadfully curious about the magistrate's large rings, one set with an amethyst and the other with some bright-yellow stone, transparent and of such a beautiful luster.

  32. 32

    And for a long time afterward he recalled with astonishment that those rings had drawn his gaze irresistibly even throughout all those terrible hours of interrogation, so that for some reason he could not tear himself away from them or forget them, as a thing utterly out of keeping with his situation.

  33. 33

    To the left, at Mitya's side, in the place where Maximov had sat at the start of the evening, the prosecutor had now settled himself, while at Mitya's right hand, in the place where Grushenka had then been, a ruddy young man took his seat, in a sort of hunting jacket, and a very shabby one at that, before whom an inkstand and paper had appeared.

  34. 34

    He turned out to be the magistrate's clerk, whom the latter had brought with him. The police captain, meanwhile, now stood by the window, at the other end of the room, beside Kalganov, who had also taken a seat on a chair by that same window.

  35. 35

    "Drink some water!"

  36. 36

    the magistrate repeated gently, for the tenth time.

  37. 37

    "I have drunk, gentlemen, I have drunk… but… well, gentlemen, crush me, execute me, decide my fate!"

  38. 38

    exclaimed Mitya, fixing the magistrate with a dreadfully motionless, bulging stare.

  39. 39

    "And so, you positively maintain that you are not guilty of the death of your father, Fyodor Pavlovich?" the magistrate asked gently but insistently.

  40. 40

    "Not guilty!"

  41. 41

    "Guilty of other blood, of the blood of another old man, but not of my father's."

  42. 42

    "And I mourn it!"

  43. 43

    "I killed, I killed the old man, killed him and laid him low…"

  44. 44

    "But it is hard to answer for that blood with other blood, with terrible blood, of which I am not guilty… It is a terrible accusation, gentlemen, as though I had been struck a blow on the forehead!"

  45. 45

    "But who, then, killed my father, who killed him? Who could have killed him, if not I?"

  46. 46

    "A marvel, an absurdity, an impossibility!.."

  47. 47

    "Yes, as for who could have killed him…"

  48. 48

    the magistrate began, but the prosecutor Ippolit Kirillovich (the deputy prosecutor, though we too shall call him the prosecutor for brevity's sake), exchanging a glance with the magistrate, said, turning to Mitya:

  49. 49

    "You are needlessly distressing yourself over the old servant Grigory Vasilyev."

  50. 50

    "You should know that he is alive, that he has come round, and that, in spite of the grievous beating dealt him by you — by his account and now by your own — it seems he will undoubtedly remain alive, at least according to the doctor's opinion."

  51. 51

    "Alive?"

  52. 52

    "So he is alive!" Mitya suddenly wailed, throwing up his hands.

  53. 53

    His whole face lit up.

  54. 54

    "Lord, I thank Thee for the greatest of miracles, wrought by Thee for me, a sinner and a villain, in answer to my prayer!.."

  55. 55

    "Yes, yes, it is in answer to my prayer, I prayed all night long!.."

  56. 56

    and he crossed himself three times.

  57. 57

    He was almost choking.

  58. 58

    "Well, it is precisely from this same Grigory that we have received such weighty testimony against you that…"

  59. 59

    the prosecutor began to continue, but Mitya suddenly leapt up from his chair.

  60. 60

    "One minute, gentlemen, for God's sake, just one little minute; I'll run to her…" — "Permit me!"

  61. 61

    "At this moment it is absolutely impossible!"

  62. 62

    Nikolai Parfenovich very nearly shrieked, and he too sprang to his feet.

  63. 63

    Men with badges on their chests seized Mitya, though he sat down on the chair of his own accord…

  64. 64

    "Gentlemen, what a pity! I only wanted to go to her for a single moment… I wanted to bring her word that the blood is washed away, gone, that blood which sucked at my heart all night long, and that I am no longer a murderer!"

  65. 65

    "Gentlemen, she is my betrothed, after all!"

  66. 66

    he suddenly pronounced, rapturous and reverent, casting his eyes over them all.

  67. 67

    "Oh, I thank you, gentlemen!"

  68. 68

    "Oh, how you have revived me, how you have raised me from the dead in a single instant!.."

  69. 69

    "That old man — why, he used to carry me about in his arms, gentlemen, he washed me in the tub when, a three-year-old child, everyone had abandoned me — he was a true father to me!.."

  70. 70

    "And so you…"

  71. 71

    the magistrate began, but "Permit me, gentlemen, permit me just one more little minute," Mitya interrupted, planting both elbows on the table and burying his face in his hands, "do let me collect myself a little, let me catch my breath, gentlemen."

  72. 72

    "All of this shakes one terribly, terribly — a man is not a drumhide, gentlemen!"

  73. 73

    "You might have a little more water…"

  74. 74

    Nikolai Parfenovich murmured.

  75. 75

    Mitya took his hands away from his face and burst out laughing.

  76. 76

    His look was buoyant; he seemed altogether changed in a single instant.

  77. 77

    His whole tone had changed as well: here sat once more a man on equal terms with all these people, with all these former acquaintances of his, exactly as if they had all met the day before, when nothing had yet happened, somewhere in polite society.

  78. 78

    Let us note, however, in passing, that at the police captain's house Mitya, in the early days of his arrival among us, had been received cordially, but later, in the last month especially, Mitya had scarcely visited him at all, while the captain, meeting him in the street, for instance, would frown heavily and return his bow only out of politeness — a thing Mitya had marked very well.

  79. 79

    With the prosecutor he was even less closely acquainted, but to the prosecutor's wife, a nervous and fanciful lady, he sometimes paid the most respectful visits, though without quite knowing himself why he called on her, and she always received him kindly, taking an interest in him for some reason right up until the most recent times.

  80. 80

    With the magistrate he had not yet managed to become acquainted, but he had nonetheless met him too, and had even spoken with him once or twice, both times about the fair sex.

  81. 81

    "You, Nikolai Parfenych, are a most skillful magistrate, as I can see," Mitya suddenly laughed merrily, "but I shall help you myself now."

  82. 82

    "Oh gentlemen, I am risen from the dead… and don't hold it against me that I address you so casually and so directly."

  83. 83

    "Besides, I am a little drunk, I'll tell you that frankly."

  84. 84

    "I believe I had the honor… the honor and the pleasure of meeting you, Nikolai Parfenych, at the house of my kinsman Miusov…"

  85. 85

    "Gentlemen, gentlemen, I lay no claim to equality, for I do understand who I am, sitting here now before you."

  86. 86

    "There lies upon me… if it really is Grigory who has given testimony against me… then there lies — oh, of course, there surely lies — a terrible suspicion!"

  87. 87

    "Horror, horror — for I do understand it!"

  88. 88

    "But to business, gentlemen, I am ready, and we shall finish it now in a single instant, because — listen, listen, gentlemen."

  89. 89

    "For if I know that I am not guilty, then of course we shall finish in a single instant!"

  90. 90

    "Is that not so?"

  91. 91

    "Is that not so?"

  92. 92

    Mitya spoke fast and at length, nervously and expansively, as though resolutely taking his listeners for his very best friends.

  93. 93

    "And so, for now we shall record that you radically reject the accusation brought against you," Nikolai Parfenovich pronounced impressively, and, turning to the clerk, dictated to him in an undertone what was to be set down.

  94. 94

    "Record it?"

  95. 95

    "You wish to record that?"

  96. 96

    "Well, record it then, I agree, I give my full consent, gentlemen…"

  97. 97

    "Only, you see…"

  98. 98

    "Wait, wait, write it down like this: 'Of violent assault he is guilty, of the grievous beating inflicted on the poor old man, guilty.'"

  99. 99

    "Well, and then within himself, inside, in the depths of his own heart, guilty too — but that need not be written down," he turned suddenly to the clerk, "that is now my private life, gentlemen, that is now no concern of yours, those depths of the heart, that is to say…"

  100. 100

    "But of the murder of my father, the old man — not guilty!"

  101. 101

    "It is a wild notion!"

  102. 102

    "It is an utterly wild notion!.."

  103. 103

    "I will prove it to you, and you will be convinced in an instant."

  104. 104

    "You will laugh, gentlemen, you yourselves will roar with laughter at your own suspicion!.."

  105. 105

    "Calm yourself, Dmitri Fyodorovich," the magistrate reminded him, evidently wishing, as it were, to subdue the frantic man by his own composure.

  106. 106

    "Before we go on with the interrogation, I should like, if only you will agree to answer, to hear from you a confirmation of the fact that, it seems, you did not love the late Fyodor Pavlovich, that you were in some sort of constant quarrel with him…"

  107. 107

    "Here, at least a quarter of an hour ago, you were pleased, it seems, to declare that you had even wanted to kill him: 'I did not kill him,' you exclaimed, 'but I wanted to kill him!'"

  108. 108

    "I exclaimed that?"

  109. 109

    "Oh, it may well be so, gentlemen!"

  110. 110

    "Yes, to my misfortune, I did want to kill him, I wanted to many times… to my misfortune, to my misfortune!"

  111. 111

    "You wanted to."

  112. 112

    "Would you not agree to explain what principles, precisely, guided you in such hatred toward the person of your parent?"

  113. 113

    "What is there to explain, gentlemen!"

  114. 114

    Mitya shrugged his shoulders gloomily, casting his eyes down.

  115. 115

    "After all, I never concealed my feelings — the whole town knows of it, everyone in the tavern knows."

  116. 116

    "Only the other day I declared it at the monastery, in the cell of the elder Zosima…"

  117. 117

    "That very same day, in the evening, I beat my father and all but killed him, and I swore that I would come again and kill him, before witnesses…"

  118. 118

    "Oh, a thousand witnesses!"

  119. 119

    "The whole month long I shouted it, everyone is a witness!.."

  120. 120

    "The fact is plain, the fact speaks, it cries out — but feelings, gentlemen, feelings, that is another matter altogether."

  121. 121

    You see, gentlemen," Mitya frowned, "it seems to me that you have no right to question me about my feelings.

  122. 122

    You may be vested with authority, I understand that, but this is my affair, my own inner affair, an intimate one, and yet… since I never hid my feelings before — in the tavern, for instance, and told everyone, every last person — then… then I shall make no secret of it now either.

  123. 123

    You see, gentlemen, I do understand that in this case the evidence against me is terrible: I told everyone I would kill him, and then suddenly he is killed — so how could it not be me in such a case?

  124. 124

    Ha-ha!

  125. 125

    I forgive you, gentlemen, I forgive you entirely.

  126. 126

    For I myself am struck to the very skin, because who, after all, could have killed him in such a case, if not I?

  127. 127

    Isn't that so?

  128. 128

    If not I, then who else, who else?

  129. 129

    Gentlemen," he suddenly exclaimed, "I want to know, I even demand it of you, gentlemen: where was he killed?

  130. 130

    How was he killed, with what, and how?

  131. 131

    Tell me," he asked quickly, running his eyes over the prosecutor and the investigator.

  132. 132

    — We found him lying on the floor, on his back, in his study, his skull battered in," said the prosecutor.

  133. 133

    — This is terrible, gentlemen!

  134. 134

    — Mitya shuddered suddenly and, propping himself on the table with his elbow, covered his face with his right hand.

  135. 135

    — We shall continue," interrupted Nikolai Parfenovich.

  136. 136

    — So then, what was it that guided you in these feelings of hatred?

  137. 137

    You declared publicly, it seems, that it was a feeling of jealousy?

  138. 138

    — Well, yes, jealousy, and not jealousy alone.

  139. 139

    — Disputes over money?

  140. 140

    — Well, yes, over money too.

  141. 141

    — The quarrel, it seems, concerned three thousand, supposedly owed to you and withheld from your inheritance.

  142. 142

    — What do you mean, three!

  143. 143

    More, more," Mitya flared up, "more than six, more than ten, perhaps.

  144. 144

    I told everyone, I shouted it to everyone!

  145. 145

    But I resolved — so be it — to settle for three thousand.

  146. 146

    I needed those three thousand desperately… so that that packet with the three thousand in it, which I knew was under his pillow, made ready for Grushenka, I counted as good as stolen from me — that is the thing, gentlemen — I counted it as my own, exactly as if it were my own property…

  147. 147

    The prosecutor exchanged a meaningful glance with the investigator and managed to wink at him unnoticed.

  148. 148

    — We shall return to this matter later," the investigator said at once, "but for now you will permit us to note and record precisely this point: that you considered this money, in that envelope, as if it were your own property.

  149. 149

    — Write it down, gentlemen, for I understand quite well that this too is evidence against me, but I am not afraid of evidence and testify against myself.

  150. 150

    Do you hear — against myself!

  151. 151

    You see, gentlemen, you seem to take me for an altogether different man than I am," he added suddenly, gloomy and sorrowful.

  152. 152

    — The man speaking to you is an honorable man, a most honorable being — and this is the chief thing, do not lose sight of it — a man who has done a whole abyss of vile things, but who has always been and remained a most honorable being, as a being, within, in his depths — well, in a word, I cannot express myself…

  153. 153

    It is precisely this that has tormented me all my life, that I thirsted for honor, was, so to speak, a martyr to honor and a seeker of it with a lantern, with Diogenes' lantern, and yet all my life I did nothing but base things, like all of us, gentlemen… that is, like me alone, gentlemen, not all — I alone, I was mistaken — alone, alone!..

  154. 154

    Gentlemen, my head aches," he grimaced in suffering, "you see, gentlemen, I did not like the look of him, there was something dishonorable in it, boastfulness and the trampling of every sacred thing, mockery and unbelief — loathsome, loathsome!

  155. 155

    But now that he is dead, I think otherwise.

  156. 156

    — How otherwise?

  157. 157

    — Not otherwise, but I am sorry that I hated him so.

  158. 158

    — Do you feel remorse?

  159. 159

    — No, not exactly remorse — don't write that down.

  160. 160

    I myself am no good, gentlemen, that's the thing, I myself am not very handsome, and therefore I had no right to consider him repulsive either — that's the thing!

  161. 161

    That, perhaps, you may write down.

  162. 162

    Having said this, Mitya suddenly grew exceedingly sorrowful.

  163. 163

    For a long while now, gradually, as he answered the investigator's questions, he had been growing gloomier and gloomier.

  164. 164

    And suddenly, at just that moment, an unexpected scene broke out once more.

  165. 165

    The point was that, although Grushenka had been removed earlier, she had not been led far away — only as far as the third room from that blue room in which the interrogation was now taking place.

  166. 166

    It was a little room with a single window, just beyond that large room in which they had danced in the night and the feast had gone on in full swing.

  167. 167

    There she sat, and with her, so far, only Maximov, terribly shaken, terribly frightened and clinging to her, as though seeking his salvation beside her.

  168. 168

    At their door stood some peasant with a badge on his chest.

  169. 169

    Grushenka was weeping, and then suddenly, when grief had pressed too hard upon her soul, she sprang up, threw up her hands and, crying aloud in a loud wail, "My grief, my grief!", rushed out of the room toward him, toward her Mitya, and so unexpectedly that no one had time to stop her.

  170. 170

    And Mitya, hearing her wail, trembled all over, sprang up, gave a shout, and dashed headlong to meet her, as if beside himself.

  171. 171

    But again they were not allowed to come together, though they had already caught sight of each other.

  172. 172

    They seized him firmly by the arms: he struggled and tore at them, and it took three or four men to hold him back.

  173. 173

    They seized her too, and he saw how she stretched out her arms to him with a cry as she was dragged away.

  174. 174

    When the scene was over, he came to himself again in his former place, at the table, opposite the investigator, and he was crying out, turning to them:

  175. 175

    — What is she to you?

  176. 176

    Why do you torment her?

  177. 177

    She is innocent, innocent!..

  178. 178

    The prosecutor and the investigator tried to calm him.

  179. 179

    Some time passed in this way, about ten minutes; at last Mikhail Makarovich, who had been absent, came hurrying into the room and said aloud to the prosecutor, in agitation:

  180. 180

    — She has been taken away, she is downstairs — will you not allow me, gentlemen, to say just one word to this unhappy man?

  181. 181

    In your presence, gentlemen, in your presence!

  182. 182

    — By all means, Mikhail Makarovich," the investigator answered, "in the present case we have nothing to say against it.

  183. 183

    — Dmitri Fyodorovich, listen, my dear fellow," Mikhail Makarovich began, turning to Mitya, his whole agitated face expressing an ardent, almost fatherly compassion for the unhappy man, "I took your Agrafena Alexandrovna downstairs myself and handed her over to the landlord's daughters, and that little old man Maximov is with her there now, never leaving her side, and I talked her round — do you hear me?

  184. 184

    — I talked her round and calmed her, I impressed on her that you have to clear yourself, so that she should not get in the way, should not bring despondency down on you, or else you might grow flustered and testify wrongly against yourself — do you understand?

  185. 185

    Well, in a word, I spoke to her, and she understood.

  186. 186

    She is a clever one, brother, she is kind-hearted — she made to kiss the hands of an old man like me, she pleaded for you.

  187. 187

    She sent me here herself to tell you to be at peace about her, and indeed I must, my dear boy, I must go and tell her that you are at peace and consoled on her account.

  188. 188

    So calm yourself, understand that.

  189. 189

    I am at fault before her — she is a Christian soul, yes, gentlemen, hers is a gentle soul and one guilty of nothing.

  190. 190

    So what shall I tell her, Dmitri Fyodorovich — will you sit quietly or not?

  191. 191

    The good fellow had said much that was beside the point, but Grushenka's grief, the grief of a human being, had pierced his kind soul, and there were even tears standing in his eyes.

  192. 192

    Mitya sprang up and rushed to him.

  193. 193

    — Forgive me, gentlemen, allow me — oh, allow me!

  194. 194

    — he cried out, "you have an angelic, an angelic soul, Mikhail Makarovich, I thank you for her sake!

  195. 195

    I will, I will be calm, I will be cheerful — tell her, out of the boundless kindness of your soul, that I am cheerful, cheerful, that I shall even begin to laugh this very moment, knowing that she has such a guardian angel as you with her.

  196. 196

    I shall finish everything at once, and the moment I am free, I'll go straight to her — she shall see, let her wait!

  197. 197

    Gentlemen," he turned suddenly to the prosecutor and the investigator, "now I will open my whole soul to you, I will pour out everything, we shall finish this in a flash, finish it cheerfully — in the end we shall be laughing, shan't we?

  198. 198

    But, gentlemen, this woman is the queen of my soul!

  199. 199

    Oh, let me say this — this much at least I will reveal to you…

  200. 200

    For I do see that I am among the most honorable of men: she is light, she is my holy thing, and if only you knew!

  201. 201

    You heard her cries: "With you, even to the scaffold!" And what did I ever give her — I, a beggar, a pauper — why such love for me, am I worth it, a clumsy, shameful creature with a shameful face, worth such love that she would go to penal servitude with me?

  202. 202

    Just now she grovelled at your feet for my sake — she, who is proud and guilty of nothing!

  203. 203

    How can I not adore her, not cry out, not strain toward her, as I did just now?

  204. 204

    Oh, gentlemen, forgive me!

  205. 205

    But now, now I am consoled!

  206. 206

    And he sank down on a chair and, covering his face with both palms, wept aloud.

  207. 207

    But these were already happy tears.

  208. 208

    In a moment he had collected himself.

  209. 209

    The old police captain was very pleased, and so, it seemed, were the lawyers too: they sensed that the interrogation was about to enter a new phase.

  210. 210

    Having seen the captain out, Mitya simply grew merry.

  211. 211

    — Well, gentlemen, now I am yours, entirely yours.

  212. 212

    And… if only it weren't for all these trifles, we would come to an understanding this very instant.

  213. 213

    There I go about the trifles again.

  214. 214

    I am yours, gentlemen, but, I swear, there must be mutual trust — yours toward me and mine toward you — otherwise we shall never finish.

  215. 215

    I say this for your own sake.

  216. 216

    To the matter, gentlemen, to the matter, and, above all, do not go rummaging so in my soul, do not torment it with trifles, but ask me only about the matter and the facts, and I shall satisfy you at once.

  217. 217

    And the trifles to the devil!

  218. 218

    So Mitya exclaimed.

  219. 219

    The interrogation began anew.

The particulars

The text
Братья Карамазовы, Fyodor Dostoevsky. Book IX — The Preliminary Investigation.
Translation
Public-domain Russian (Dostoevsky, d. 1881). Translation © 2026 1732 Studios.
Words
Every word of the text, by letter.
Data
JSON · Markdown · A guide for agents
Two whoopie pies and a pine. An inside joke.